Homestar forgets a TV joke, Strong Sad tries to return a missed call, Strong Bad and the King of Town both "claim" responsibility for the prank calls, and Strong Mad attempts a prank call on an answering machine.
Strong Bad, Strong Mad, and The Cheat go toilet-papering. Strong Sad and Marzipan try to contact the spirit of Credenza, her dead ficus plant. The rest of the crew go trick-or-treating.
Bubs grows 100 feet tall and wreaks havoc onto Free Country, USA. So, Strong Bad, Homestar, The Cheat, and the others must come up with a plan to save the day.
The King of Town threatens to reveal Marzipan's secrets, Homestar chases blondes, Bubs looks for women, Coach Z wants a backup singer, The Cheat leaves a prank call, and Marzipan's questionable surgeon calls.