Plastic China (2016) Poster

(2016)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
This reality is so ironic.
leewinglum21 January 2018
This documentary did a really great job at making contrasts between modernity and agricultural life. A dreamlike product in the developed countries becomes wasted and is shipped to a former small agricultural village in China. People there wanted to thrive someday by decomposing the wastes. The packages and publications from the waste make them dream. Kids made themselves capes , computers and auto shows, and the "boss" wanted to buy a dream car in the future. The poison we considered in the cities becomes their bed for sweet dream.

It is beyond my imagination and keeps me rethink the recycling industry because it can transfer the damage to other countries to recycle and claim that the product is environmentally friendly without seeing the actual recycle process. But at the same time it is also an industry depend on wastes and it is on which people live. This documentary really raised a dilemma: How could we make the protagonists' life better? Should we cut down this kind of industry? However as the Kun said:" I don't have other skills. I do it for living." then, should we produce more wastes? Do they have to live like this?
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Slow in all the right ways
toriamiddleton7 September 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Plastic China is unlike any environmental documentary I have seen before. It does not waste its screen time giving you big scary numbers and graphs. It's almost like I got invite to stay with theses people for a few weeks. It's a simple movie but, A complex subject. This movie starts off with the showing of mountains upon mountains of trash and the families that work and live among this mess. At first, I thought that some guy was going to talk throughout the film staying why this is bad and go bag free. But no, this movie trusts that you know that already and that you know that there are people in the world that live like this. The documentary actually stars an 11-year-old girl name Yi-Jie who works sorting out trash with her parents miles away from her home town. Yi-Jie is also the oldest child and has to help take care of her siblings with one being a newborn. There is no main story line just a couple of small life events. Boss wants to send his four-year boy to a preschool but at first could not afford it. By the way, Yi-Jie does not go to school because her Dad, who also drinks, think he can not afford it in the city. He is wants to save money for a train ticket to send her back to her hometown to go to a free school with her uncle. The two families the boss and Yi-Jie's work on low wages and keep dreaming about buying better things like cars, phones, and computers. They even go to a car show and someone said these cars equal almost ten years of work in the trash field. But when Yi-Jie Dad thinks that he has enough money for a train ticket, he goes to the station only to find out that he is short. There is no happy ending, no big reveal, or surprise. Yi-Jie goes back to what she knows best, picking up trash.

The film clearly shows why China wants to stop collecting the worlds trash. In the big cities there are entire areas that do nothing but trash sorting. This affects kids and grown ups health. All Yi-Jie and her siblings do all day is play in trash and breath in the smoke from the burning plastic. Even though Yi-Jie does not go to school, she learns from all the paper and books that end up in their trash. On the surface it seems like fun to find an American candy bar, German bags, and Russian cloths all day. I was laughing at the fact that these children use the resources that they have with such an imagination. However, the grown ups know what they do is hurting them and, they think that buy bigger and better things will be worth all that hard work. After they are done with that bigger and better thing, they will throw that away for someone else to sort. It is a cycle and China is now making its own trash because of the amount of middle-class people now. The boss wants what other people have, to use more resources. He wants to be the one tossing the trash not picking it up. Because you can not do both. This movie does show you the result of too much plastic being brought to China. This movie teaches you to be happy for what you have and to watch what you throw away because it may end up in a child's hand.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Heartbreaking...
smartypantsz28 September 2020
A must see.

To watch these families 'exist' in their world - especially the eldest daughter - is hard to watch, but this is a must see film, just to see how the 'other half' lives.

We live our lives, using things and throwing them away. These people are on the exact opposite of our actions.

Tough to see.

The pacing was perfect I thought.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Outstanding, understated and unforgettable
DennisLittrell14 November 2017
This very interesting documentary shows the life of two Chinese families three generations deep living on, beside and surrounded by plastic waste. Their job is to turn the plastic into pellets to be sold to industry.

It's a Chinese language film with English subtitles. The focus is on 11-year-old Yi Jie, daughter of Pen who works for "boss man" Kun who has come in from the country where he was a farmer to recycle plastic waste so he can afford to pay for education for his children (and no so incidentally) buy nice things like a new car. We see the children at work and play among and amidst the piles of mostly white plastic. We see the workers and children sort through the plastic for the right kind to feed the machine that makes pellets that can be sold. The children play, the families eat together, they sing, they joke, they moan about making the equivalent of five dollars a day. They dream, and strange to say learn a lot about the world by examining and reading the plastic trash from all over the world.

I learned a bit about plastic recycling some twenty years ago when for two months I walked the streets of the beach cities in the Los Angeles area collecting bottles and cans. I found out then that the plastic that was not deposit bottles was gathered into great shipping crates and sold to China. In turn many American companies bought the resulting pellets from China! This film shows why it was economic to ship the plastic waste to China and then effectively speaking buy back a value-added product. Quite simply the labor costs were and are so much less.

Curiously this is an uplifting doc with almost no political message. Because the people are shown going about their daily lives we come to feel we know them, and indeed their hopes and dreams and the way they live with one another is very much like people everywhere.

Director Jiuliang Wang demonstrates in this film that he has a fine eye for the right kind of detail and a good sense of people and even how to tell a story, because, yes this is a story, a true one about people living in poverty but filled with hope. Wang is also the director of "Beijing Besieged by Waste" (2012) which I haven't seen yet.

--Dennis Littrell, author of "The World Is Not as We Think It Is"
23 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Be Better
EggOrChicken25 April 2019
Yeah, it's a documentary, but it says more about us as humans. It's more of an artistic exposition of what we are becoming. And with the utmost respect for the humans here, we need to be better at it. Save the earth and we save ourselves.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Informational, yet saddening
smithryann8 December 2021
Warning: Spoilers
In the film "Plastic China", two Chinese families are documented for surviving off the work of recycling plastic waste. Though recycling is known as a good deed, this film shows the hardships these families and the Chinese people live with. They suffer from a lack of access to education and health issues that stem from the garbage and harsh conditions in which they live. Not only are the people suffering from health concerns, but the environment also faces pollution and fish are dying in the local community. The film shows how harsh plastic waste can truly be, which in my opinion is not what I was expecting to see. The recycled materials we throw away end up in landfills in China and creates more of a mess than we intended. I would rate this film very informational, yet also very sad to see how people live around the world.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Ver slow and repetitive
dianebrauch29 August 2019
It would make a good 30 minute doc but what he has here is repetitive. It's a sad, interesting story but by the 30 minute mark you get the tragedy, the hopelessness. how long can you watch people sort and refine plastic? I would not recommend this doc. It was torture to watch in many ways.
1 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed