Thomas and his friends are making a Halloween vlog, when suddenly the light goes off. When it returns, Dominic is dead, and later disappears. The others panic as they disappear one by one while Thomas stubbornly wants to continue vlogging.
Thomas is joined by a group of cartoon voice actors. Thomas' viewers have previously sent him random phrases attached to one particular cartoon character, and the actors must deliver these phrases playing these characters.
Thomas and his friends tell some positive news and facts that have happened on the year 2016, tell some jokes, and do anything they can to try and cheer up anyone viewing that might feel sad, depressed or in despair for any reason.
Thomas has previously sent his viewers several poll-like questions in a "X versus Y" format. He and Ben J. Pierce answer themselves each question and then try to guess what answers got the majority of votes from the viewers.
Thomas and Jon Cozart have been repeatedly shipped together by people. Now they do a test to check if they really are compatible, by answering both the same questions and trying to get both the same answer.
Thomas gives some advices on how to treat people on Christmas time, especially trying to remember there are people that feel most unhappy at this time of the year, so he encourages people to try to make them feel welcome and better the best they can.
Thomas and Grace Helbig play a game where they type on Google incomplete phrases sent by the viewers on Twitter, and Thomas and Grace must try to guess how Google is going to complete the phrase on the results.
Brayden asks his uncle Thomas to make up a Christmas bedtime story. Unconsciously, Thomas let's metaphors go about a recent breakup he was still mourning about, disguised as a Santa Claus story poem that helps him subtly unburden his pain.
Thomas talks about how when he gained weight he felt bad about himself, and says men do have body negativity too, but reminds that appearance doesn't matter. It's how the person is inside what counts, and everybody is beautiful in some way.
Thomas shows some of the gifts his viewers have given to him while on the "Ultimate Storytime" tour and on other meetings, and gives his thanks to them, also for the best gift of all for him, the love and support from his followers.
Thomas tries to answer some questions about black history that are thrown to them by some of his black best friends, Dahlia Johnson, Leo Anderson and Terrence Williams Jr.
Viewers through Twitter have sent Thomas plots that could belong to a real Anime or be made up by them. Thomas must guess if the plots that Dominic reads to him are fake or if they are real anime shows.
Celebrating Women Month in America, Thomas is joined by a group of women friends who throw some questions at him about women in history, and he must try to guess the correct answers.
Thomas and Joan try to explain sports to the viewers, but since they are not exactly experts on sports, their answers are probably not gonna be accurate, so to speak.
Earlier, Thomas asked his followers on Twitter to submit short videos saying random words, sounds, making faces, movements, etc. He'll use some of them to fill in the gaps of different stories he narrates as the Storytime Guy.
Once again, viewers have sent Thomas plots that could be either from real anime shows or made up by themselves. Dominic reads some of them to Thomas and he must guess if the plot is a real anime or if it's been made up.
Thomas and Joan test their improvisation level on acting by doing various sketches without a dialogue script and including some sentences being picked randomly from a cap full of papers with them written on.
Once again, Thomas joins some friends to throw positive news and facts, jokes, and anything they can to try and cheer up anyone viewing who might feel sad, depressed or in despair for any reason.
It is Autism Acceptance Month, so Thomas is joined by a group of friends, some of the suffering Autism or Asperger's Syndrome, who throw at him some questions, and he must try and guess the correct answers.
Thomas, dodie and Ben J. Pierce join to perform a cover of "Waving Through a Window" from the Broadway musical "Dear Evan Hansen", which they have just seen together the night before.
Thomas and Joan try to answer some questions about cars that are thrown at them by the viewers, but since they're not precisely experts on cars, their answers are not going to be accurate, to say so.
Once again, Thomas has asked his followers to submit some video saying random words, making noises, doing movements, etc, and Thomas, as the Storytime Guy, will tell some stories with gaps filled with some of these videos chosen randomly.
Thomas watches and reacts to some DVDs of stage musicals he has done in the past, including "The Forbidden Planet", "Jesus Christ Superstar", "High School Musical", "Hot Mikado", "Peter Pan", "Singing in the Rain" and "The Producers".
It's Asian American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month, so Thomas is joined by some friends of that ethnicity who throw questions at him about the topic, and he must guess the answers.
Thomas, Joan and Talyn play three old videogames from Thomas' childhood. They score them before hand based on their memories, and after playing they update their score based on how they see them today.