"The Defeated" First Trick (TV Episode 2020) Poster

(TV Series)

(2020)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Interesting
rudicantfail26 November 2021
This seems like a storyline that might prove to be very watchable. It seems from this first episode that a lot of effort has been put into making this authentic looking, even if it is using CGI. Attention to detail is rather accurate, and the year it is set in, 1946, is portrayed seemingly very well; a city in absolute turmoil. However, it has also shown a stupidly lame this production is, and I refer you to the two boys standing next to an unexploded bomb complete with a Union Flag on the side of it. How bloody dumb is that? Every nation put their flag on its bombs! Stupid. But we shall see how the next episode goes.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Somewhat enjoying...so far
tjmac_otr29 August 2021
On the third episode. Fairly good writing and acting but,......why do writers, actors and/or directors seem to think it's ok to inject modern aspects to period pieces??? Taylor Kitsch, SHAVE!!!!! No self respecting American man in 1946 would appear with stubble. Even in the condition Berlin was in during that time. I personally (and admittedly petty) find it distracting.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
How did I keep going after this junk?
coltsw-1080316 September 2021
Warning: Spoilers
The overall premise as it is established here in the first episode is silly and historically impossible. The war has been over for a year, yet there are no young German men around, so the new police department for the entire city of Berlin is a crew of about two dozen centrally located women and oddly silent older men, who have no budget, no training or experience, no vehicles, and they are not allowed to carry firearms. Where are all the German servicemen who returned from the war by 1946? They weren't ALL war criminals on the run or still in POW camps. The goof who wrote this idiotic tale did absolutely no historical research. NONE!

So for some extremely odd reason the U. S. Government sends a lone American civilian cop to the American controlled sector of Berlin to set up a new police agency that is "up to the standards of the NYPD", he proudly announces in his moronic accent. What a laugh! It never happened, nor would it ever.

Before that, he has just gotten outwitted and beaten up by two very young street urchins, and shortly thereafter he confronts two mad dog, heavily armed and inexplicably rampaging Soviet soldiers with only his Colt pistol, breaking cover to do so. It's so idiotic. If they were hoping to establish this clown as a brave tough guy, they failed miserably. The whole show fails miserably, especially with this first episode.

Another moronic subplot includes a Me-Too-style revenge conspiracy that is gratuitous and apparently is supposed to make women feel empowered, I guess. By rewriting history? How about we focus on the present and the future. Trying to change facts from the past only makes one look like a fool.

It's so hard to decide what is the worst aspect of this completely pathetic mess? I have to say it's either the amateurish writing or everything about Taylor Kitsch, from his awful acting, to his laughably anachronistic appearance (his stubbly beard is a late-20th Century abomination), to his grossly incompetent and annoying fake "New Yawk" accent. The character is a bumbling boob who cusses like a 21st Century, Generation Z hipster and shows no signs of being a competent cop.

The city of Berlin looks to be a complete, 100% ruin from the outside, with no complete buildings left standing. But all the interiors shots are of fully furnished and complete apartments and offices. The supporting cast is OK, except some of the uniformed characters are appear much too old for their role, especially the cadaverous old Soviet army commander.

Probably the absolute dumbest part of the first episode is the ending, where we find out what Kitsch's character's older brother, an AWOL American soldier, has been up to, and the reaction of the lead character with the stupid and terrible fake accent. Total nonsense. Again, it's the ludicrous writing. SO bad!
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Will be Surprised if it gets past two seasons
adcmelb16 March 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Dull if not weird plot about an American that goes to post war Berlin to set up an American style police station that is mainly staffed by women. As the storyline gets underway it doesn't surprise that the plot was written by a "woke" feminist". I understand that post war Germany had a manpower shortage but this episode ha plenty of males in secondary role but the local police are entirely staffed by women, another scene has the heroic NYPD guy and his female assistant take down two Russians armed with machine guns all with one pistol and a wooden baton before more Russians arrive to save their comrades, another scene has two American soldiers lured away from their guard duty by a vengeful German woman to save her cat so these soldiers can be attacked by a gang of vengeful German women. The second episode will have to be a vast improvement for the rest of the series to watchable.
2 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Review in Progress....
wandernn1-81-68327421 August 2021
Interesting concept. As IF.

American Cop sent to supervise German Police After WW2. Now HQ is a converted bank. Russian soliders are shooting kids in the 'US sector', is the first dilemma he faces.

American soldiers raping German women sets the scene for German women to capture 2 American soldiers.

At the office of displaced persons, Supercop goes to the front of the line and makes demands and is thrown out by the Russian clerk. Good for the Russian Clerk. Asshat cop doesn't deserve special treatment.

In Progress.....
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed