Let me start by saying that I am a big fan of the books and did love the 1985 take on this (of course Anne of Green Gables - The continuing story was dreadful), however I always welcome a fresh look at such a wonderful series.
Like most others who have rated this, I really wanted to embrace it and felt that the first episode was a great start. I thought most of the casting was great, scenery beautiful and OK somethings were changed/added but I didn't mind so much in this episode.
It was when Episode 2 went completely off the rails with Anne being returned to the Orphanage, Matthew trying to find her and then her deciding to make her own way to Halifax, I mean wasn't there enough in the Novels to make up garbage like that. Did it add to the story - no.
Now we are in the 21st century I am sure we can appreciate that Anne certainly had a distressing history being passed around from family to family, OK fine to perhaps explore that her past was not always sunshine and roses. Yes, I am sure as well as an angsty teenager she would be prone to lash out. But the new series argh!!!
Anne became a social outcast, rejected by the community and other students at school until she rushed into a burning building to save some of the Gillis family. By this stage I was tempted to turn it off but decided to see it through for the remaining 4 episodes.
Other items of disbelief was insinuating Diana's Great Aunt Josephine had a female life partner and her great love whom she was mourning (of course this would happen in the 1800's but did she need to have a backstory?). Gilbert becoming an Orphan and leaving school to work on the docks with a view to joining a steamer so he can travel.
The final episode of Season 1 ended on a "cliff hanger" with two men with the intention of robbery/violence/kidnapping moving into Green Gables as borders, it did cross my mind whether they were intending to set up a Meth Lab in the Green Gables Barn for Season 2.
I don't think I will be going back for Season 2
32 out of 49 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends