It's interesting but overrated, and it glamorizes serial predators. Also, even as someone who's watched gory films since they were a little kid, I can see how the gore would seem excessive and disturbing to some people (not me). Even though a show like The Walking Dead has a lot of gore, it's the sick and horrific framing of it in Hannibal that I think a lot of people couldn't accept (especially on network television).
I'm in a minority, but I HATE Hannibal Lecter. People get so goo-goo over him and Will's relationship, but it's clearly an horrifically abusive relationship. I loathe Hannibal (as I should) for his abuse of Will (and others), a mentally distraught person who needed real help. Even so, the exploration of what happens when you put a mentally unstable person into the hands of a master manipulator is the best and the most frustrating aspect of the show. But people, as they always do, took the wrong message from it. It's not love. It's not sexy. It's not admirable. It's abuse. I don't mind the thinking aspects of the show. I get it. But some more black-and-white minded people could not see past the veil. A person who lacks empathy cannot truly love. Hannibal didn't love Will. He was simply entertained by him and wanted to be wanted by him, wanted a companion like him so he wouldn't be alone in his madness. That's not love. That's codependence. And both the audience and the show itself increasingly showed that they didn't get that.
For me, the Manhunter version of Hannibal remains the scariest version (and Manhunter the most underrated film) because he seemed normal. We got so little of him in that film, but you could see both the affable charm and the desire to brutally destroy in his eyes, and that's unsettling. I believed that version of Hannibal. Mads is too flat. I don't dislike him in the role, but he gave nothing except amusement when someone would do something so rude that Mads would make a "what TF?" face. I did, however, love his fight scenes. The smartest thing the show did was show that he could be hurt. Even so, he wasn't not one iota scary. The show could have easily just been about him being a manipulative therapist and it would have hit me the same.
I've seen people placing it above the first season of True Detective and the good seasons of Game of Thrones, and I strongly disagree. The special effects are low quality and almost laughable at points, though the makeup and practical effects are impressive. They spam certain things when they're not necessary (the stag and the dark horned man) for a thinking person. They keep characters around for too long (Abigail, Freddie) and lean too much over the line of sympathizing with those we shouldn't instead of presenting a purely objective viewpoint. A rational person, even one with strong empathy, should see the danger of Hannibal. But so many people take the wrong message from his relationship with Will. They just see two good-looking men and their desire to be dominated ("their," as in viewers who clearly need therapy themselves) kicks in.
It was something a cut above most network television, but it was not quite prestige television. The same ingredients on cable or a streaming platform and it could have had the budget and better writing to be a contender. To be honest, it reminded me of The X-Files several times (especially the music, the tone, some of the brutal slayings), but The X-Files was a much better show.
Oh, and I won't even get into all the plot holes and plot contrivances and plot armor because it'd be several more paragraphs. But I will say that this show is a perfect "that's not how that works" example.
I'm in a minority, but I HATE Hannibal Lecter. People get so goo-goo over him and Will's relationship, but it's clearly an horrifically abusive relationship. I loathe Hannibal (as I should) for his abuse of Will (and others), a mentally distraught person who needed real help. Even so, the exploration of what happens when you put a mentally unstable person into the hands of a master manipulator is the best and the most frustrating aspect of the show. But people, as they always do, took the wrong message from it. It's not love. It's not sexy. It's not admirable. It's abuse. I don't mind the thinking aspects of the show. I get it. But some more black-and-white minded people could not see past the veil. A person who lacks empathy cannot truly love. Hannibal didn't love Will. He was simply entertained by him and wanted to be wanted by him, wanted a companion like him so he wouldn't be alone in his madness. That's not love. That's codependence. And both the audience and the show itself increasingly showed that they didn't get that.
For me, the Manhunter version of Hannibal remains the scariest version (and Manhunter the most underrated film) because he seemed normal. We got so little of him in that film, but you could see both the affable charm and the desire to brutally destroy in his eyes, and that's unsettling. I believed that version of Hannibal. Mads is too flat. I don't dislike him in the role, but he gave nothing except amusement when someone would do something so rude that Mads would make a "what TF?" face. I did, however, love his fight scenes. The smartest thing the show did was show that he could be hurt. Even so, he wasn't not one iota scary. The show could have easily just been about him being a manipulative therapist and it would have hit me the same.
I've seen people placing it above the first season of True Detective and the good seasons of Game of Thrones, and I strongly disagree. The special effects are low quality and almost laughable at points, though the makeup and practical effects are impressive. They spam certain things when they're not necessary (the stag and the dark horned man) for a thinking person. They keep characters around for too long (Abigail, Freddie) and lean too much over the line of sympathizing with those we shouldn't instead of presenting a purely objective viewpoint. A rational person, even one with strong empathy, should see the danger of Hannibal. But so many people take the wrong message from his relationship with Will. They just see two good-looking men and their desire to be dominated ("their," as in viewers who clearly need therapy themselves) kicks in.
It was something a cut above most network television, but it was not quite prestige television. The same ingredients on cable or a streaming platform and it could have had the budget and better writing to be a contender. To be honest, it reminded me of The X-Files several times (especially the music, the tone, some of the brutal slayings), but The X-Files was a much better show.
Oh, and I won't even get into all the plot holes and plot contrivances and plot armor because it'd be several more paragraphs. But I will say that this show is a perfect "that's not how that works" example.
Tell Your Friends