Props to the OPLA creative team, the fact this show exists and has been great for the most part is a miracle. For context I'm up to date on the manga and I've been really enjoying this show so far, I especially love how they've made changes to deliver the story in a way that doesnt take up 5 episodes each fight.
However, this episode completely missed the mark for me, they just cut too much out for run time. Honestly why does syrup village and baratie get 2 whole episodes while arlong park only gets 1.5? For me, this wasn't the emotional gut punch that I expected, in large part due to these memorable moments from the source material being left out:
1. Nami finding out the entire village knew all along... The sacrifice everyone made in cocoyashi village so Nami wouldn't feel burdened is the emotional core of this story. It's also why i cared so deeply about cocoyashi village surviving. Deleting this aspect which could've at most taken 5-10 minutes in the LA doesn't make sense to me because it's not exactly an expensive plot point to deliver? There's no VFX required to include this.
2. Nami's "i'll be able to smile again" moment
3. Bellemere lying at first then changing her mind as arlong is walking away, not having this was a deal breaker tbh.
4. hatchan being left out, what implications does this have for sabaody?
5. Genzo has a huge role in the manga, he is essentially the father figure for nami and nojiko but in the LA he has like... 3 lines? I understand you need to cut stuff out, but he's part of the emotional core of Nami's character, so much so that the pinwheel is 50% of her new tattoo, representing how much he means to her. How will they address this in season 2, given how neglected Genzo was in this episode?
The music also felt incredibly overdramatic during the marine seizing scene, and the help me scene. I love how the anime used no music at all in the help me scene, the music here was distracting and made the scene feel goofy with how overly dramatic it was.
Still, the series' quality so far has been a welcome surprise, and I'm very much looking forward to how they'll adapt the alabasta saga, hopefully for accuracy Vivi will be played by Emily Rudd in a blue wig.
However, this episode completely missed the mark for me, they just cut too much out for run time. Honestly why does syrup village and baratie get 2 whole episodes while arlong park only gets 1.5? For me, this wasn't the emotional gut punch that I expected, in large part due to these memorable moments from the source material being left out:
1. Nami finding out the entire village knew all along... The sacrifice everyone made in cocoyashi village so Nami wouldn't feel burdened is the emotional core of this story. It's also why i cared so deeply about cocoyashi village surviving. Deleting this aspect which could've at most taken 5-10 minutes in the LA doesn't make sense to me because it's not exactly an expensive plot point to deliver? There's no VFX required to include this.
2. Nami's "i'll be able to smile again" moment
3. Bellemere lying at first then changing her mind as arlong is walking away, not having this was a deal breaker tbh.
4. hatchan being left out, what implications does this have for sabaody?
5. Genzo has a huge role in the manga, he is essentially the father figure for nami and nojiko but in the LA he has like... 3 lines? I understand you need to cut stuff out, but he's part of the emotional core of Nami's character, so much so that the pinwheel is 50% of her new tattoo, representing how much he means to her. How will they address this in season 2, given how neglected Genzo was in this episode?
The music also felt incredibly overdramatic during the marine seizing scene, and the help me scene. I love how the anime used no music at all in the help me scene, the music here was distracting and made the scene feel goofy with how overly dramatic it was.
Still, the series' quality so far has been a welcome surprise, and I'm very much looking forward to how they'll adapt the alabasta saga, hopefully for accuracy Vivi will be played by Emily Rudd in a blue wig.
Tell Your Friends