Reviews

4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
1/10
What a mess
8 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I had to give a rating of 1 just to balance out all the hyped reviews.

This episode had far too much nonsense and felt like an insult to my intelligence.

First of all- why are the enterprise crew to believe they're in the "wrong" timeline just because it's not the one the viewer is used to? Every human believes they're in the "correct" universe, it's the other universes that should prove themselves worthy. And all of this because Guinan has an intuition about it? Who died and made her admiral?

Secondly who cares for Tasha Yar? The most blank character gets revived only to get an empty romance story and affect a past event that we learned is extremely important just 10 minutes before?

All of this for the main universe to end up as if this all never happened? Well then why'd it have to happen at all? An empty story entertaining an empty possibility that ended up affecting nothing from the POV of the original universe. And all entirely predictable from the very beginning. It's as if this episode didn't even air. And maybe that's what should've happened.
4 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Bney Or (2021– )
10/10
An in-depth exploration of life in the Israeli Periphery
11 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Transports you directly into the family drama, neighbourhood dynamics and the spontaneity with which youth crime emerges in the poorer areas of Israel.

Much like Breaking Bad, a seemingly good cause- an expensive drug rehabilitation treatment for a suicidal father- serves as the catalyst for the protagonist's need to make a quick buck, this time by selling the drugs, rather than manufacturing them. Luckily he has his (less than) trustworthy group of friends to assist him in this endeavor. As expected, trials and tribulations ensue, fuelled by complications like law enforcement, organized crime, and the power dynamics created by the different personalities and motivations in our teenager group. This ends up making for a very turbulent trip into money land, with the promise of money serving really more as a tool/metaphor for influence and self actualization for the teens who are starving for it. Given how very different their environment is from Walter White's, it provides plenty that is original, and makes for an intriguing, dark, and very close-up view into growing up in the Israeli periphery, with testosterone and camaraderie being key players in this drama.

As I'm a Beershevian myself it is interesting to observe the amount of low-key precision in the depiction of the cultures, psychology and mannerisms involved, and together with the yellow tones of the outside environment and close up shots of the inside one, the show becomes surprisingly realistic, which adds to its intensity. I truly appreciate this show as a work of art, and I think it's easily material for a cult classic. R. I. P Guy Balila.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A real gem.
21 January 2020
Warning: Spoilers
This trilogy gives you a glimpse of what reality is like in times when the individual who follows his own moral compass gets crushed by the multitude because they have neglected theirs. Contrary to popular belief, there's no glory in being the crucified, dying for our sins. We all want Kaji to triumph, but Kaji cannot triumph alone. If we don't ALL do our best to be Kaji, we don't deserve Kaji.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A simple soldier's view of this film.
12 October 2013
Hello, my name's Jacob. I'm a 21 year old guy, from Israel, forced to join the army at the age of 18 as nearly all people of my country have to, forced to waste 3 years of my life doing things I'd never want to do if only I was allowed to choose. I'm not a great movie buff. I'm a simple person, and I'd rather play a video game to kill time, but I do like action and war films which is how I got to see "The human condition" on some list here on IMDb. Sounded interesting, and so I decided to watch the 3 films. So this is a review about all 3...

The films accurately demonstrates, maybe to the extreme, what it is to be a peace-loving, good human being, in a place where fascism and cruelty reigns supreme. Some people may say that Kaji's character is too unbelievable. Too saint-like, to the point where it becomes frustrating. I say it's not true- It's a movie, not real life. Kaji's behaviour might not be realistic, he faces humanity's worst traits with his own altruist ideals of pacifism and equality, as if he's some sort of WW2 superhero. Saying one cannot identify with him is wrong, however, in my humble opinion, because even if maybe you wouldn't act the way he did when put in the same situations, you can appreciate the way he handled himself, you can admire him and aspire to be like him. He isn't a saint though, he makes mistakes, born out of the cruelty and misery that surrounds him, betraying at times the "code" that he is supposed to protect and follow, but even then, you know that ultimately deep down he's the same person, no matter how things go.

Seeing many many irrational things in my military service, I can relate to Kaji in many ways. Seeing people who dedicate their lives to controlling others for the sake of getting promoted, to get appreciated by their superiors who actually appreciate them about as little as they appreciate their own soldiers. People who care for their own interests far more than they care for the interests of those they are in charge of, crushing their wants and needs and deeming them unimportant in the blink of an eye, while their own interests take much higher priority... People who enforce and follow strict rules that are unbending and unreasonable, with such a passion, that it makes you think any reasonable man would dismiss those people as insane, yet still, those are the people who are in charge, because they are the ones who stay in the army and dedicate their lives to it and to it's incredible stupidity, while the real reasonable people go on to dedicate their lives to do something that might actually be beneficial to humanity. This has now officially become somewhat of a rant of how terrible military life and discipline is, maybe more so than it is a review of this series of movies. But why I am saying all of this? because these observations of mine- they are accurately depicted in this movie. If only these real life people that I know were just trying to be a bit better, a bit more human, more like Kaji, maybe my impression of what the army is like wouldn't have been so gloomy as they are now. Kaji, in the films, tries-everywhere he goes-to set things right for those around him, he goes through so many terrible things, scenes that are so... Vile, and so distorted from what you think of human nature as it is in our usually comfortable modern life, and with sheer willpower, he triumphs, even if his triumph is just in him, staying alive while everything else is gone. But ultimately, does it do him any good? If he were to die in the first movie, would that have been better? saved him the suffering of everything he went through later? Well, that is for you to decide. What these films have taught me, is that no matter how it ends, it is important for a person to do what he sees as the right thing to do, and to never lose sight of what the right thing to do is... I'd define a good movie as one that makes you think at the end. It doesn't have to be a cool plot twist at the end that makes you think, it just has to be a movie complex enough but also engaging enough to make you think at the end, because you didn't have time to figure out everything you wanted while you were watching it. At the end of the third movie however, I didn't have to think of anything. I had already absorbed everything. All I wanted was to sleep, and just couldn't. My mind was empty, and I could feel only one thing- awe. And that is why I rate "The human condition" 10/10.

I'm terribly sorry if what you just read sounded like a bunch of drivel. Maybe this review is not for you, and maybe the movie is not for you. But regardless, I thank you for reading it to the very end. Have a nice day.
73 out of 78 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed