Issues with rogue one and why it's not Star Wars
The characters are for the most part terrible, unlikable, evil, or poorly executed. The Disney fingerprint is heavy on these characters with disregarding there should only be American or English accents, and most of the casting choices. The female character beating up piles of men including men in armor. The girl being mean, angry, violent, heartless.
Stormtroopers being beaten up with sticks.
Horrific music Terrible dialogue Disney inventing characters that serve no purpose like the main villain in white. Then bending existing characters around these new characters, so that it's incredibly embarrassing hearing tarkin and Vader talk about these new characters like they're important. Just a huge problem with the writing in general of bending the entire story around the characters invented for this film and making all of the galactic universe revolve around them.
Disney inventing droids and starships in vehicles and guns and inserting them where they never existed in the original films a complete perversion of the Star Wars universe. The Star Wars universe is the tone is the story is the fantasy is the heroism is the fun of the 1st 3 movies. The Star Wars universe is not Gray it's good and evil. The rebels are good they're not doing evil stuff. Heroes that we follow in the Star Wars universe are not dying left and right, sometimes a main character dies or a side character, but Star Wars movies are not about suicide missions, they're not about everyone getting killed. Thankfully all these characters were awful so I didn't care about any of them dying but if this was actually a good movie up until that point it would have been inexcusable. The Star Wars universe is not about gritty dark ideas about realism. You can't say I want to make this genre of movie in the Star Wars universe or I want to make that, at that point it's not happening in Star wars even if it has a Star Wars skin.
Donnie yen should have had some type of lightsaber weapon, and the stupid repeated mantras were horrible to listen to and should never have been done.
The whole che guevara character, and really all the storylines of the first two acts were terrible and not Star Wars.
The third act could have worked with likeable characters, lore accurate vehicles and weapons, no imperial officer antagonist, no death star showing up, no planetary Shields, and having the main characters escape.
The characters are for the most part terrible, unlikable, evil, or poorly executed. The Disney fingerprint is heavy on these characters with disregarding there should only be American or English accents, and most of the casting choices. The female character beating up piles of men including men in armor. The girl being mean, angry, violent, heartless.
Stormtroopers being beaten up with sticks.
Horrific music Terrible dialogue Disney inventing characters that serve no purpose like the main villain in white. Then bending existing characters around these new characters, so that it's incredibly embarrassing hearing tarkin and Vader talk about these new characters like they're important. Just a huge problem with the writing in general of bending the entire story around the characters invented for this film and making all of the galactic universe revolve around them.
Disney inventing droids and starships in vehicles and guns and inserting them where they never existed in the original films a complete perversion of the Star Wars universe. The Star Wars universe is the tone is the story is the fantasy is the heroism is the fun of the 1st 3 movies. The Star Wars universe is not Gray it's good and evil. The rebels are good they're not doing evil stuff. Heroes that we follow in the Star Wars universe are not dying left and right, sometimes a main character dies or a side character, but Star Wars movies are not about suicide missions, they're not about everyone getting killed. Thankfully all these characters were awful so I didn't care about any of them dying but if this was actually a good movie up until that point it would have been inexcusable. The Star Wars universe is not about gritty dark ideas about realism. You can't say I want to make this genre of movie in the Star Wars universe or I want to make that, at that point it's not happening in Star wars even if it has a Star Wars skin.
Donnie yen should have had some type of lightsaber weapon, and the stupid repeated mantras were horrible to listen to and should never have been done.
The whole che guevara character, and really all the storylines of the first two acts were terrible and not Star Wars.
The third act could have worked with likeable characters, lore accurate vehicles and weapons, no imperial officer antagonist, no death star showing up, no planetary Shields, and having the main characters escape.
Tell Your Friends