I have seen some good Hitchcock movies: The Birds, Psycho, and The Lady Vanishes rank among them. This does NOT.
I found Number 17 to be such a disappointment! The plot had appeal(some strangers try to figure out what's supernatural about a hotel room), but this movie is an epic fail.
Before I get into that, let me start with what works. The plot did engage me at times, and the acting is somewhat decent. About half the movie was satisfying.(I almost gave this a 4 but decided to "meet the middle man").
Now, let's talk about the issues I had with this movie:
1. The picture quality sucks. Okay, I know this movie is 88 years old, but Frankenstein and City Lights are both a year older and they look much better! And fine, Scrooge from 3 years later looks poor too, but still! Couldn't someone restore this movie a bit?
2. Ben, the sidekick character, talks WAY too softly. His accent also gets out of the way out of understanding 99% of what he says. Unfortunately the DVD I saw this on did not include subtitles.
3. The movie sometimes goes a few minutes without any dialogue, which can work, but here it doesn't seem to. My mind wandered when this happened.
4. Plot-wise, not everything makes sense, and you can't tell why everything is happening in the story. Some of it's even boring, especially the end that seems to drag without a clear destination.
5.There was also a scene that could have been avoided if the characters noticed their surroundings. 2 people lean against a banister and you can clearly hear it crack but it has to FALL for the characters to notice! This makes such a scene cliche and not suspenseful.
Unless you want to see every Hitchcock movie ever made, or want something on while you do housework, Number 17 is the Number 1 Hitchcock movie to avoid.
Note: This is an edit of a review from 10/9/19.
I found Number 17 to be such a disappointment! The plot had appeal(some strangers try to figure out what's supernatural about a hotel room), but this movie is an epic fail.
Before I get into that, let me start with what works. The plot did engage me at times, and the acting is somewhat decent. About half the movie was satisfying.(I almost gave this a 4 but decided to "meet the middle man").
Now, let's talk about the issues I had with this movie:
1. The picture quality sucks. Okay, I know this movie is 88 years old, but Frankenstein and City Lights are both a year older and they look much better! And fine, Scrooge from 3 years later looks poor too, but still! Couldn't someone restore this movie a bit?
2. Ben, the sidekick character, talks WAY too softly. His accent also gets out of the way out of understanding 99% of what he says. Unfortunately the DVD I saw this on did not include subtitles.
3. The movie sometimes goes a few minutes without any dialogue, which can work, but here it doesn't seem to. My mind wandered when this happened.
4. Plot-wise, not everything makes sense, and you can't tell why everything is happening in the story. Some of it's even boring, especially the end that seems to drag without a clear destination.
5.There was also a scene that could have been avoided if the characters noticed their surroundings. 2 people lean against a banister and you can clearly hear it crack but it has to FALL for the characters to notice! This makes such a scene cliche and not suspenseful.
Unless you want to see every Hitchcock movie ever made, or want something on while you do housework, Number 17 is the Number 1 Hitchcock movie to avoid.
Note: This is an edit of a review from 10/9/19.
Tell Your Friends