Review of Asylum

Smallville: Asylum (2004)
Season 3, Episode 9
3/10
Psychiatric hospitalization sensationalism
11 March 2019
Overall, interesting episode. It was a great idea to have Clark re-encounter three former classmate-villains from seasons 1 and 2. My main critique is with ho Belle Reeve is portrayed. I worked at a state psychiatric hospital for 10 years, and this episode sensationalizes mental illness and psych hospitals and promotes the stigma against mental illness. Hospitals- * are well-lit and use bright, pleasant colors * do often have beds attached to the floor, but they're cots with mattresses, pillows, and blankets * allow patients to wear their own clothes, within reason * do not look like jails with metal toilets * do not have walls of windows looking into patient rooms * do not use batons, metal cages, padded rooms, and straitjackets anymore, and haven't for a long time * do not allow ROCKS or other weapons on-site * have opportunities to engage in arts and leisure activities, but not in public places * maintain patient confidentiality by having visitors only visit in specific places, not on the units * do not have patient fights on a regular basis, as people with mental illnesses are no more violent than the rest of society

I have this same critique for other episodes of this show. I look forward to the day that TV and movies portray people with mental illnesses accurately and respectfully.
11 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed