Review of Return to Peyton Place

This is really a terrible film that makes the 1957 original look like a great film -- which it certainly wasn't. The story, such as it is, is contrived beyond any credulity. Believe it or not, it was based on the eponymous novel by author Grace Metalious, obvious intent to capitalize on her minimal writing skills. Metalious herself held the work in poor esteem, claiming she was pressured by Hollywood producer Jerry Wald to write the sequel. But it should be noted that she didn't let her disdain overcome her greed. With one notable exception, the performances are absolutely horrible. That one exception was the great Mary Astor, one of the most versatile actresses and Oscar winner from films in the 30's and 40's. This was one of her last screen roles, but even she couldn't work miracles.