Secret of the Blue Room (1933) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
41 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Atmospheric and entertaining mystery
RJV3 June 2000
Because it was released by the premier horror studio Universal, focuses on an old castle with a spooky room, and features horror star Lionel Atwill, SECRET OF THE BLUE ROOM has been marketed as a horror film throughout the year. It's actually a whodunit with horror elements that influence but never dominate the film. But it would be close-minded to reject this film just because it's not a full-fledged chiller. SECRET OF THE BLUE ROOM is an enjoyable film that projects an air of menacing mystery and efficiently moves the plot with a palpable suspense until the movie's resolution.

SECRET OF THE BLUE ROOM benefits from attractive sets (leftover from THE OLD DARK HOUSE and FRANKENSTEIN) that convey an ornate yet forbidding castle milieu. Director Kurt Neumann, while no stylist in the James Whale vein, effectively utilizes the setting's atmospheric potential. He provides a suitably eerie aura with taste and restraint, avoiding obvious stunts like self-playing pianos. Such gimmicks would damage the film's mood and credibility.

On the whole, performances are good. The actors and actresses provide believable characterizations that help propel the plot. Particularly impressive are Lionel Atwill as the castle owner troubled by his estate's secrets and Edward Arnold as a detective who handles the castle's mysteries in a domineering, no-nonsense manner. Elizabeth Patterson is mildly annoying as a terrified maid, but fortunately her performance doesn't affect BLUE ROOM's atmosphere.

Curiously, a few of the plot's riddles remain unexplained at the film's end. It would have been logical for Universal to provide a sequel with the same fine cast in order to resolve everything. Instead, the studio chose to remake the film twice with different performers. But BLUE ROOM's minor plot holes shouldn't detract one from enjoying this well-made mystery.
23 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A MUST for fans of classic mystery!
binapiraeus20 February 2014
This is certainly one of THE classic 'old mansion murder mysteries' that were so popular in the 30s; and it can contend with most of the very best of them. A great challenge for every mystery fan who likes to guess the murderer, because the plot takes so many turns and twists that it's really hard to follow even for a 'murder expert'! The settings are excellent, following the classic scheme of the old, elegant but somehow frightening isolated country house, with solid wooden stairs, long dark corridors with knight's armors in every corner, distinguished old-fashioned furniture - and a dark room with an old DARK mystery...

The cast is magnificent, headed by mystery expert Lionel Atwill, and beautiful Gloria Stuart (who had also played in "The Old Dark House" a year before) as the object of desire for no less than three young men; Edward Arnold, well-known to friends of more down-to-earth gangster movies and comedies, as the blunt detective, Paul Lukas as the suave foreign 'officer and gentleman' - even every bit part was casted just perfectly! In my opinion, an absolute 'must' for any fan of the classic mysteries of the 30s - and a good opportunity for others, who are not too familiar yet with the genre, to get to know it WELL and at its BEST!
20 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Secret Of The Blue Room (1933) ***
Bunuel197614 July 2005
Warning: Spoilers
SECRET OF THE BLUE ROOM is competently made, with atmosphere to spare, but doesn't particularly stand out from this type of film and this, I guess, is one of the reasons why it isn't well known today. It boasts a fine cast, certainly, but they're not really inspired by the material: Atwill is merely a red herring and isn't even the lead character despite his top billing; Gloria Stuart's role is nothing compared to the one she played in THE OLD DARK HOUSE (1932), though she does get to sing in this one!; Paul Lukas is an interesting hero: dapper, mature and sporting a heavy Hungarian accent a' la Bela Lugosi!; Edward Arnold's belated entrance, in my opinion, brings the film to life after a rather slow first half. As for the mystery, well, after the tale told by Atwill about what occurred in the Blue Room all those years ago, one expects an explanation by the film's end but this aspect is never properly resolved (nor is the business about the stranger who breaks into the mansion): instead, we get a 'twist' ending which had actually occurred to me as I lay watching the film but had subsequently dismissed as being too obvious! All in all, apart from some stilted dialogue (courtesy of William Hurlbut, who lated wrote BRIDE OF FRANKENSTEIN [1935]!), SECRET OF THE BLUE ROOM is a very entertaining little film which could have been more interestingly developed - but the main thing here is watching these wonderful actors and the Universal house-style in action.
25 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Very Underrated
Michael_Elliott11 March 2008
Secret of the Blue Room (1933)

*** (out of 4)

Forgotten Universal mystery/horror film about a haunted room that kills whomever stays the night in it. Is it a ghost or something else? I was shocked to see how well made this film was and the direction added some nice atmosphere along the way. The story is very well written with a nice mystery and a wonderful ending that certainly caught me off guard. The only weak part is some of the police investigation. Stars Lionel Atwill and Gloria Stuart. Rare but certainly worth searching for. I might even prefer this to The Old Dark House, which shared some of the same sets as this film.

Remade twice by Universal.
19 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A little creaky but enjoyable
utgard149 April 2017
Not bad little Old Dark House quickie from Universal with a great cast and a "guess you had to be there" plot. A trio of horndogs (Paul Lukas, Onslow Stevens, William Janney) want to marry pretty Gloria Stuart, despite her warbly singing voice. So they decide to have a contest to see who gets her hand. All three men will spend one night in the "blue room," a supposedly haunted room of a spooky old mansion where three murders were committed twenty years earlier. Then the fun starts. In addition to the top talent already mentioned, this one also features Paul Barrat, Lionel Atwill, and Edward Arnold. Pretty good lineup. It's definitely worth a look for classic film fans. Probably won't blow you away or anything but I doubt you'll feel your hour and change was wasted.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Great Airport Read
LanceBrave23 November 2013
This is, what, the fourth classic Universal horror film to start with the same rendition of Swan Lake? "Secret of the Blue Room" revolves around a mansion with a cursed room, were three unsolved murders have occurred over. In order to impress the object of their desire (Third time in a row Gloria Stuart has shown up), three suitors each decide to spend a night in the seemingly haunted room. Murder follows, mysteries are investigated, and red herrings abound.

If this movie was a book, we'd call it a great airport read. It's generally unremarkable and didn't offer anything particularly new, even in 1933. The film is a straight mystery with only marginal horror elements. There's some light Gothic trappings, such as a silhouette shot of the mansion right out of "The Cat and the Canary" and a great scene of Gloria being attacked by a fedora clad villain, who we naturally only see in shadow. The climax takes place in a spider web covered secret dungeon. The cast is good, truthfully. Lionel Atwill, as the girl's father, plays up his natural creepiness. William Janney as the youngest suitor and Paul Lukas, with his strong accent, are both more interesting then your typical Hollywood romantic leads of the time. My favorite performance has to be Edward Arnold as the detective. His uncompromising interrogation techniques make the second half of the movie energetic and fun. Mary the cook provides some amusing comic relief, with her anxious insistence not to be incriminated in the case.

I was sort of surprised to find out the movie isn't based on a stage play, with its small cast and limited locations. It's not a particularly memorable film but it is a decent way to spend an hour, a good example of the sub-genre. Universal was weirdly fond of the story, remaking it twice, in '38 as The Missing Guest and in '44 as Murder in the Blue Room, a musical/comedy. Funnily, each was in black and white meaning we just have to take the movie's word on the titular room's primary color.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Oft told story of a challenge to stay in a cursed room to win the love of a woman is one to see thanks to a sterling cast of Universal regulars
dbborroughs4 August 2006
Three men all in love with the same woman decide to spend the night in the cursed "blue" room where tragedy strikes who ever spends the night. Of course tragedy again strikes and the police are called into solve the crime.

Grand Universal mystery thriller suffers from having been remade both officially and unofficially over the years. The film itself is a remake of an earlier German film so I guess turn about is fair play.

Feeling more like an old friend rather than a griping thriller this film is a good little mystery. Odds are you'll know whats going on, but you won't mind since the cast is the real reason to see this. Paul Lukas is a dashing military man, Lionel Atwill is the owner of the cursed house, Gloria Stewart is the woman in question and Edward Arnold is the detective called in to solve the crime. They are all aided by a strong supporting cast of Universal studio regulars.

This is one to make an effort to see especially if you're a fan of good, if familiar, mysteries.

7 out of 10 due to the passage of time and the multiple remakes.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Accent On Blue
davidcarniglia4 August 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Entertaining old dark house murder mystery. The premise is unique, and the plot unfolds nicely. The house, Helldorf castle, is really the star, with its forbidden room, secret passageways, suits of armor, a gargoyle here and there, and a pond below the infamous blue room.

Lionel Atwill doesn't have much to do here; the three suitors for Gloria Stuart's affections aren't much as characters, with the exception of Walter, who's really too old for her anyway. To slightly rake over the coals brought to light by other reviewers, there's not really any memorable performances, the plot hints at events that aren't resolved, and the setting itself is ambiguous.

There's only one murder that's accounted for, the one Thomas confesses to. The Commissioner could at least ask Thomas about the earlier victims, or Atwill's Van Helldorf could mention that the Commissioner might reopen those unresolved cases. That Thomas would kill to get Irene is plausible; but there was something strange about how the secret passageway denouement was set up.

We see Walter shoot his dummy, apparently in an attempt to flush out the real killer. But when he enters the blue room, he immediately finds the entrance to the secret passageway, and descends the gothic innards of the castle. Apparently, Walter has deduced that the killer hangs out down there. But if he knew that much, why wait to confront the killer? Why not get some of the policeman to help? He almost gets himself killed; his shot only serves to warn Thomas. Maybe the police put the dummy there without telling Walter, so at first he was fooled and thought it was the killer. Even though I watched that scene twice, I'm sure I still missed something.

When Irene's real father shows, a lot of possibilities open up: for a bit I thought she might be the killer. Nothing wrong with a dead-end spur of the plot. But, even if the mysterious father doesn't figure in the plot resolution, the revelation of his identity was an interesting device that deserved more exploration.

As cool as the castle looks, both inside and out, just where is it? Looks too old to be in the U.S. The castle's and family's name suggest Germany, or, we could just compromise and say England. That in itself isn't such a big deal, but when some characters have American accents, others have English accents, and there's other accents as well, it becomes a distraction.

There were other distractions that worked. The hyper maid stirred things up nicely. The cat poking around in the blue room, as well as the butler's sudden entrance in the dining room were well-timed bits that kept everyone on edge.

Secret of the Blue Room entertains, but to be more enjoyable it needs a few more rooms. 7/10.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A standard dark house mystery with a few twists.
planktonrules10 June 2017
During the 1930s, there were a ton of 'dark house mysteries'...films where a murder takes place at some creepy house or mansion. The cops end up investigating and eventually it's all sorted out by the end...and there are usually a few more bodies by the time it's all sorted. Because of this, there is definitely a sameness to this movie as these others...though fortunately there are enough differences to make it interesting.

The film begins with Irene's 21st birthday. Apparently she (Gloria Stuart) is quite the catch, as three men are there vying for her affection at this little party. To prove his rugged manliness, the youngest of her suitors promises to spend the night in the Blue Room. Why is this so scary? Twenty years ago, three people died there...and it's been bolted shut ever since. The two other suitors join him and by morning, one of them is dead. Soon the inspector (Edward Arnold) arrives and tries to figure out what happened.

It's interesting that the same exact musical intro occurs in this film as "Dracula"....made by the studio two years earlier. "Swan Lake" was reused and most folks might not recognize it...and the IMDb trivia draws attention to this.

So is it any good? Well, it does help that the film has some excellent actors in it, such as Lionel Atwill and Paul Lukas. He and the rest of the cast do a competent job with the story
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Early talkie mystery
jonfrum200028 February 2012
Considering it's age, a pretty good old dark house/castle movie The acting is a bit stilted, as one would expect for the year it was made This is a locked room mystery, in which multiple people have been/are killed in the castle 'blue room' The film starts out slow with a love quadrangle (!) and a full length song, but gets going after that, The earlier mystery that the plot is based on is never explained, and leaves us wondering at the end, Paul Lukas plays with a strange Bela Lugosi accent, which i found annoying, but i got used to it eventually, Worth watching for genre fans, but it would have been better if they waited a few years to make it
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
There's a prize to be had...if you make it through the night!
mark.waltz8 June 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Any Universal film that starts off with the music of "Swan Lake" over the credits gets attention in my book, whether it be horror or romantic melodrama. And for this basically forgotten old dark house thriller to start off that way (and last only 65 minutes!), you know you're hooked!

This is a gathering at a scene of a long ago murder, inside the blue room, which is utilized for three men who desire the hand in marriage of the heroine (Gloria Stuart). Of course, like "And Then There Were None", the number decreases, comedy and thrills increase, and the revelation is not what you expect. This has a great cast, especially Elizabeth Patterson as the deaf, yet still wise-cracking cook, who doesn't want any murders happening on her shift since that could ruin everybody's appetite.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Gloria Stuart Did have Talent!!!
kidboots28 January 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Gloria Stuart was plunged into controversy before she had even appeared in a film. She became the subject of a bidding war between Paramount and Universal. Later on she regretted the fact she did not sign with Paramount but at the time she seemed happy to go to Universal as they were offering more money. Initially Universal had big plans for Gloria and had glowing praise for the actress they thought would star in their high class productions. But Universal's hopes drifted off course and while she was given roles in prestigious productions they were usually only set decoration. OK, Universal wasn't Paramount, but it did have James Whale to give a touch of class and make classics of a lot of its horror productions. Though not as successful as "The Old Dark House", "The Secret of the Blue Room" did have some effective moments and a "I never would have guessed it" ending. The eerie music as it introduced the stars (who wouldn't be scared by the look of terror on Robert Barratt's face) boded well for a gripping movie and I was not disappointed.

As the clock strikes twelve Robert Von Helldorf (Lionel Atwill) toasts his daughter Irene's (Stuart) birthday with a creepy phrase "No one will love you like I" - knowing Atwill you know he will definitely not allow anyone else to love her like him!!! The first red herring!! Irene's three suitors sit around the table until Tommy (William Janney) begs Robert to tell them about the blue room which has been locked for twenty years but he is very reluctant. It had been the scene of three uncanny deaths and now only Paul (Barratt), the ominous butler, has the key.

To prove their bravery the foolhardy trio vow to spend a night each in the blue room, Tommy going first and of course in the morning he is nowhere to be found. Irene is menaced by a strange man and Frank (Onslow Stevens) vows to wait for him - in the blue room, where else!!! And then there was one - Captain Walter Brink (Paul Lucas) quickly calls the Police Commissioner (Edward Arnold, sounding and acting more like a policeman than he did in "Remember Last Night"). All the usual suspects are paraded for his inspection, including a vindictive maid (Muriel Kirkland), a surly mechanic (Russell Hopton) who definitely looks and acts as though he has something to hide - I actually thought he was an undercover policeman, I must have a vivid imagination as the reality was much more down to earth!!! As well as a startling confession by Robert!! There were also secret passages, a chase along a dark, damp stairway and a car that went missing at inappropriate times!!!
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The things we do for Love
Coventry2 January 2019
One of the many, many reasons why I love watching these really old (1920s - 1940s) mystery/drama films is because the stories, or at least pivot aspects of them, seem so outdated and unworldly by today's standards. Take the basic premise of "Secret of the Blue Room", for instance. Three men are rivaling for the love of beautiful 21-year-old Irene; daughter of the prominent Lord Robert Von Helldorf. To decide who marries her, they agree that each one of them must spend a night in the mansion's fearsome Blue Room; a guest chamber where nobody has set foot since three mysterious and still unresolved deaths occurred there 20 years earlier. Alright, solid and compelling enough thriller plot, but has anyone noticed that the girl in question - Irene - isn't supposed to have an opinion? The men decide that one of them will marry her, the father approves for the test to take place under his roof and that the stake is his own daughter's hand, but lovely Irene simply must accept that the identity her future husband will be determined by a game of bravery and stubbornness instead of love, respect or gallantry. Crazy old days. Thank goodness for the evolution of women's rights and feminism throughout the years!

Anyways, my silly rant aside, "Secret in the Blue Room" is a mystery-thriller just the way I like them: short (65 minutes) and straightforward, with qualitative dialogues and absorbing red herrings. The denouement isn't too difficult to figure out in case you've seen similar whodunits before, but I reckon it's quite a convoluted climax for a 1933 film. Despite being one of Universal's lesser known productions from the 30s, the film can still depend on a strong ensemble cast, including veteran actors like Lionel Atwill and Paul Lukas, and a surefooted young director. Kurt Neumann was only in his mid-twenties when he made "Secret of the Blue Room", and his career abruptly ended in the 50s with modest Sci-Fi classics like "The Fly" and "Kronos". Female lead Gloria Stuart already showcased her acting talents here, as well as in "The Old Dark House" and "The Invisible Man", but she would only truly famous 65 years later, thanks to her role in "Titanic".
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Standard 1930s Mystery
Rainey-Dawn10 September 2018
This is your typical or standard 1930s cutesy mystery-horror film. Nothing special about it. The only real reason to watch it is for Gloria Stuart and Lionel Atwill if you like them.

4/10
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Pleasant Universal Creaker!
BaronBl00d29 June 2003
A bit rusty and dusty, this film made by Universal in 1933 tells of three men infatuated with the daughter of Lionel Atwill who all agree for sake of ego to stay in the mysterious "blue" room, a room where no one has gone into for twenty or so years because of all the terrible things that befell the inhabitants of that room. Gloria Stuart plays the beautiful object of their affection and carefully plays on the sidelines as each man prepares and stays in the blue room. What happens? Well, that would be giving too much away, but what does ensue is a nice, tight mystery for the most part with some credible red herrings and a somewhat plausible and innovative resolution. Lionel Atwill does a fine job in his patriarchal role as does Stuart. Paul Lukas, Onslow Stevens, and the rest of the cast also do fine jobs. Story really moves this film along, and the script is very good for this time period and for a mystery. My print was somewhat faded and I am not sure if a crisper print exists. I hope so. I know it will be sometime - if anytime - for this film to get the proper DVD treatment is deserves.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Predictable, but with a good cast
Leofwine_draca23 December 2020
Warning: Spoilers
SECRET OF THE BLUE ROOM is a minor Universal horror/mystery from 1933, very similar in tone to the likes of THE OLD DARK HOUSE but not as iconic. Gloria Stuart, also of THE INVISIBLE MAN fame, co-stars and a lively cast is what lifts this out of the doldrums. The predictable storyline involves three men making a bet to stay in a room with a murderous past, with predictably spooky results. There's not much plotting here but then the film does last just over an hour in length; the biggest annoyance is that nobody ever thinks of a secret passage. Heck, I knew all about them by the time I was 10 from the kid's books I used to read! Lionel Atwill is a welcome presence as the patriarch figure.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Groovy Ghost Story/Mystery
GroovyDoom27 March 2001
Warning: Spoilers
A castle with a closed off room is the setting for this murder mystery that features a group of men who dare one another to sleep in the castle's "haunted" room to prove their manhood to the movie's eligible bachelorette, Irene.

There isn't much going on with that plot, so the film gives us a subplot involving the servants and their affairs. Meanwhile, the men staying in the "Blue Room" either disappear or are murdered one by one, while Irene watches on in helpless horror.

Interestingly, this is a Universal Pictures release, and while it's got no monsters in it, it is obviously intended as a riff on "The Old Dark House" (Irene is actually played by Gloria Stuart, a holdout from the cast of "The Old Dark House"). The Gothic elements of the setting are played to the hilt, with stormy weather, dark hallways, secret passages, and hidden agendas going on all around. The sets are spooky without being covered in cobwebs, although a scene later in the movie involves a chase through a hidden hallway that finally gives us some webs.

These cliché aesthetics are offset by the extremely dated attitudes and humor in the film, intentional and otherwise. You start to wonder what these characters do in their lives. It's easy to understand why Irene and her father are idle, because they are rich, but what are the other three men doing there, and why does Irene's father host them? Why does it seem they've been living there for months on end with no real purpose? In this way, the movie entertains as a period fantasy, giving us characters who have no responsibility other than to dress in formal wear for dinner and tell ghost stories in the sitting room late at night.

Overall the movie is very slight, and there's not much to revisit once the film's rather obvious secret is out and you find out whodunit. But those with an affection for the old dark house trappings will definitely want to pay a visit.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Dull programmer
westerfieldalfred21 December 2013
Warning: Spoilers
I last saw this film 30 years ago, remembering only the final chase down the innumerable underground stairs. Seeing it again I see why that's all I remembered. There is no feeling of suspense. The lighting is bright and uninteresting, the directing bland, the actors simply walking through their roles with some of them being downright amateurish. Lionel Atwill shows not a trace of evil intent, immediately removing him as a red herring. The three suitors have no chemistry with Gloria Stuart or for that matter with each other. The only actor that adds some mystery to the film is Robert Barrat as the butler. The under-appreciated Barrat could play anything believably - judge, madman, sophisticated jewel thief.

A few comments about the accuracy of previous reviewers' statements. The Swan Lake title theme was used for Dracula but amended for The Mummy and as such used for Murders in the Rue Morgue and Blue Room. A short studio composed prologue was added as the faces of the pyramid rotated.

No sets from The Old Dark House were used in Secret of the Blue Room. It is possible that some details such as wood paneling and stair case portions were re-used.

The lowest staircase is identified as the cellar from Frankenstein. This is problematic. The Frankenstein set had a solid floor; Blue Room had flowing water. This same set with rushing water was rented for White Zombie, intimating that it was new or substantially rebuilt for an unknown Universal film subsequent to Frankenstein. Blue Room also had a stone arch in the foreground, lacking in the Frankenstein cellar.

Paul Lukas was not imitating Bela Lugosi; he had an identical accent.
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Entertaining old dark house adventure
csteidler14 March 2019
The clock strikes midnight. It's Gloria Stuart's 21st birthday and she is celebrating over a late dinner with her father and three eager suitors.

The happy conversation soon turns to the castle's blue salon, a room that has been locked for 20 years. Three people died mysteriously in that room, all those years ago. One of the suitors proposes a challenge: he plans to spend the night in the blue room if his each of his rivals will do the same over the next two nights.

Things happen pretty quickly over the next several scenes: Suitor number one disappears, the butler converses in low tones with a stranger at the kitchen door, a mysterious attacker frightens the daughter, suitor number two is shot....

The plot is pretty standard but it's fast paced and has a couple of twists. The usual old dark house corners and shadows are put to good use. There's also the classic shot where the camera pans slowly across the suspects' faces, one by one, close up.

Gloria Stuart is fine as the beautiful daughter. Lionel Atwill is appropriately suspicious as her shifty father. Paul Lukas is rather dashing as the best of her suitors (although his accent is a bit distracting). Midway through the picture, Edward Arnold enters the scene as a clever and dogged police detective who's determined to get to the bottom of things.

Lively characters, plenty of suspense, a bit of humor - exactly what you would expect from a Universal picture with this title. Lots of fun.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Fun Little Secret
daoldiges3 February 2024
Secret of the Blue Room takes place in a big, creaky old mansion on a dark and stormy night, of course. To me it is oddly populated by an odd grouping made up of a father, his daughter who live in the mansion, and three men all of which are in love with the daughter and each trying to win her to their side. That just seems a little too on the nose for me but oh well. One of the rooms is apparently haunted and one of the suitors challenges the others to spend a night in this haunted room to prove his ultimate love for said daughter. I won't reveal any more except to say that it is a little predictable but the all-around solid cast, and the sets all overcome the routine story to provide a somewhat fun little mystery worth checking out.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Unnecessary Universal Remake that is Enjoyable
Reviews_of_the_Dead22 May 2023
This was a movie that I almost watched by accident originally. When I was doing my Trek through the Twos, I found this version streaming on YouTube. It was when I was settling in to watch this and see who stars in this one that I realized it was wrong. From there and looking further I learned that Universal did a remake with more bankable stars a year after the original came out. I'm now watching as a Traverse through the Threes.

Synopsis: twenty years after 3 murders occur in a castle's 'blue room', three men who each want to marry a beautiful girl decide to spend a night in the room to prove their bravery to her.

We start this at the stroke of midnight. It is Irene von Helldorf's (Gloria Stuart) 21st birthday. She is at the manor where she lives with her father, Robert (Lionel Atwill). Also, there are the three suitors from the synopsis. Capt. Walter Brink (Paul Lukas) who is in the military, Frank Faber (Onslow Stevens) who is a newspaper reporter and then the youngest is Thomas Brandt (William Janney). With the singing done, they head into another room for drinks. Tommy takes Irene aside and proposes. She doesn't respond to it and joins the others.

Irene is asked what she wants to do for her birthday. She picks to hear a spooky story. Tommy brings up what happened years ago in the blue room of this manor. This stiffens Robert who is pressed into telling the tale. Three mysterious deaths happened. The first was his sister. It seems she leaned too far out of the window and fell to her death. The next was his best friend. Finally, there was a detective who stayed in the room soon after and he mysterious died as well. What makes it even more weird, all the deaths occurred at 1 AM.

Listening to this and seeing his chance, Tommy proposes a challenge. The three men will stay in the room on consecutive nights. The rules are that you stay the whole night or forfeit. He volunteers to stay in the room on that first night.

Tragedy strikes when the butler, Paul (Robert Barrat), goes to check on him the following morning and there's no answer. The men all break into the room. Tommy isn't there. The window is open and it makes them think of what happened twenty years ago with Robert's sister. Something also happens with Frank the next night. There is a gunshot and when they get in, he's dead. How did someone get into this locked room though?

Commissioner Forster (Edward Arnold) is then called in to investigate. Robert and Walter are suspects along with Paul, Betty (Muriel Kirkland) who is a house cleaner and the chauffeur, Max (Russell Hopton). Mary (Elizabeth Patterson), the elderly cook, is even questioned. There is also this stranger, played by Anders Van Haden, who showed up the first night and keeps coming to the backdoor of the manor. Things aren't as they seem and the secret of this mysterious room will need to be uncovered.

That is where I'll leave my recap and introduction to the characters. Where I'll start is that this is interesting to watch a year after the original. I remembered what the reveal was. I was curious if this version was going to do anything different and it doesn't seem like it. What I will say though, I was able to settle in and watch for little things that I might not have noticed with the original German version. This is just done through Universal with their cast.

With that I've said there, that isn't necessarily a bad thing. This is unnecessary though. Outside of making it in English so viewers do not have to read subtitles. I will argue that this has the better star, Atwill. The rest of the surrounding cast is on par. Since I've already been going into it, I'll explore the rest of the actors. Atwill is good as the patriarch here. He has a brooding nature about him. He doesn't want to rehash the fateful events that make up the legend of the blue room. He is pushed into it by his daughter and Tommy. It is wild to see a young Stuart, as I know her from Titanic when she was an old woman. She was quite attractive and good in this role. Lukas is solid along with Stevens and Janney. The latter doesn't have a large role, but it is important. Other than that, I thought the rest of the cast rounded this out for what was needed in building the mystery.

I'll shift over to the story then, since that is what I normally focus on. This film is light on the horror elements, most likely being here because we get a murder mystery. They tended to fall into my genre during this era. We also have elements of 'The Old Dark House' with secret passages and what not. I'm a sucker for this. What I like the most though is using the lore of what happened twenty years ago and that cycle repeating. This time I noticed that Tommy's disappearance mirrors what happened to Robert's sister. Then we have a death like his best friend. The police are then involved for that third night. That was something that worked for me as well.

All that is left is filmmaking. I think that the setting is one of the best parts. We have this large and dark manor. It seems like castles or places like this would have history. They tend to be old and hold generations of a certain family. Building on that with the 'Old Dark House' and the mystery of this specific room. The cinematography doesn't do anything out of the ordinary which is fine. It is still early in the history of cinema. We don't get much in the way of effects. It is also that type of movie. Other than that, the soundtrack fit what was needed. The use of silence or characters listening to what is happening in the blue room does add an element for me.

In conclusion, this is a fine remake. I'd also say it isn't necessarily since it is beat for beat. The story we got was interesting. I like where it goes with elements of murder mystery and 'The Old Dark House'. The acting is better only because we have the likes of Atwill. The rest of the cast is solid. This is made well enough. It doesn't necessarily do anything to stand out there. I enjoyed my time here even though this didn't do anything new. I'd only recommend if you like the history of American cinema as this is a solid film from the era.

My Rating: 7 out of 10.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Haunted History
Cineanalyst26 October 2018
While Universal was spending lavishly on its other horror pictures--even splashing six figures for a stinker like "Murders in the Rue Morgue" (1932), while investing over $300,000 in the classic "The Invisible Man" (1933)--"Secret of the Blue Room" cost a relatively-paltry $69,000. Judged on this basis, for the bang of one's buck, it's a successful B-production. Although usually lumped together with Universal's classic horror films, it's more of a murder mystery, or whodunit, set in a creepy castle. It's in the same vein as films such as "One Exciting Night" (1922), "The Monster" (1925), "The Bat" (1926), "The Cat and the Canary" (1927) and "The Bat Whispers" (1930), except with less comic relief and no clear stage origins. That it's a haunted castle rather than a house seems to point to its German roots, and, indeed, it's credited as a remake of a German film, which I haven't seen (seemingly, nor has anyone else recently), made the prior year. An earlier German picture, which I have seen and is available today, that I'm reminded of is F.W. Murnau's "Schloß Vogelöd" (often translated non-literally as "The Haunted Castle") (1921).

Another connection is James Whale's "The Old Dark House" (1932), for which the title has become something of a name for a subgenre of horror films set in spooky houses on stormy nights. The main room of the first floor of the castle here is the same set constructed for Whale's production, and Gloria Stuart starred in both. Like other old dark house movies, a storm blows doors open, there are ghost stories, secret passages, a locked unkept room with a haunted history, a strange man, suspicious housekeepers, nervous maids, a screaming and fainting heroine and a detective investigating murder. "Swan Lake," one of only two melodies to be heard here, also plays at the beginning and the end, as it did in "Dracula" (1931), "The Mummy" (1932) and "Murders in the Rue Morgue." The resolution for this one is rather untidy in leaving the room's history unexplained, but I respect the production's no-frills treatment. The frequent use of wipes in editing being about the closet thing here to showy filmmaking.

Stuart's role as the ideal form of femininity here seems more thankless and, today, rather cringe inducing for different reasons than her part in "The Old Dark House," where Whale exploited it for the sexual perversities and proclivities of the house's stranger occupants, including homosexuality, incest and attempted rape. Nothing of the kind appears here; yet, her father imploring her to kiss him and her three suitors, which she obligingly does on the lips for each, seems almost as weird today. She also plays the piano and sings a love song for them. To top it off, Stuart delivers the lines, "Oh, it must be terrible to be a man and have to be brave. Thank goodness I can be a coward with a clean conscience."
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
First seen on Pittsburgh's Chiller Theater in 1968
kevinolzak11 April 2011
1933's "Secret of the Blue Room" was a remake of a 1932 German film titled "Geheimnis des blauen Zimmers," and even uses a few exterior shots from the original, while all interiors were filmed on the same marvelous sets built for James Whale's "The Old Dark House" (1932), also seen in independents such as "The Vampire Bat" and "Strange People." The last of the vintage Universals to utilize Tchaikovsky's serene "Swan Lake" over its opening credits (following "Dracula," "Murders in the Rue Morgue," and "The Mummy"), it begins on a suitably blustery midnight, celebrating the 21st birthday of young Irene von Helldorf (Gloria Stuart), along with her father Robert (Lionel Atwill), and three determined suitors, police captain Walter Brink (Paul Lukas), newspaper reporter Frank Faber (Onslow Stevens), and the much younger Thomas Brandt (William Janney), who impulsively proposes marriage to Irene on the spot. Mocked by the others, the young Brandt brings up the locked blue room, where Irene's mother had died 20 years before, with two others falling victim within since the original tragedy, all at the stroke of 1:00AM. Betting each of his rivals that they must all spend a night in the forbidding salon, Brandt seeks to prove his bravery by going first, only to disappear without a trace before morning, the bed not even slept in. Von Helldorf is reluctant to phone the police, until on the second night, a shot rings out from the blue room, and Faber is murdered at 1:00AM. Lionel Atwill heads a superb cast in his Universal debut, and Edward Arnold turns in some solid sleuthing, as he later would in the 1935 James Whale whodunit "Remember Last Night?" Formerly husband and wife in Whale's "The Kiss Before the Mirror," are Paul Lukas and seductive Gloria Stuart (disrobing just as her jealous husband shoots her dead); she would next appear in Whale's "The Invisible Man," while Lukas would turn up in Whale's "By Candlelight." Part of the original SHOCK! package of vintage Universal horror classics released to television in 1957, this remake was itself twice remade by the same studio, in 1938 as "The Missing Guest," and in 1944 as "Murder in the Blue Room," both of which changed the backstory and added different characters (in this 1933 feature, no one solves the 20 year old mystery of the blue room). Neither of the two remakes were included in the SHOCK! package, but all three turned up on Pittsburgh's Chiller Theater, with four broadcasts for "Secret of the Blue Room" - May 18 1968 (following 1959's "Terror is a Man"), May 24 1975 (following 1940's "Chamber of Horrors" and 1943's "Calling Dr. Death"), Mar 5 1976 (following 1957's "The Deadly Mantis"), and Sept 10 1983 (solo).
18 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Night of Terror
lugonian10 May 2021
SECRET OF THE BLUE ROOM (Universal, 1933), directed by Kurt Neumann, is a murder mystery often mistaken for a horror film. Aside from starring horror legend, Lionel Atwill, the opening credits begin with the composition to "Swan Lake," the scoring that opened other Universal horror tales as DRACULA (1931), MURDERS IN THE RUE MORGUE (1932) and THE MUMMY (1932). Of the three mentioned, SECRET OF THE BLUE ROOM is the least known, let alone revived. Regardless of this being an overlooked item by many, Universal remade it again as THE MISSING GUEST (1938) and again as MURDER IN THE BLUE ROOM (1944), the latter containing more humor than thrills.

Set in Germany at the old Eldorf Castle, the narrative begins at the stroke of midnight where the gathering of guests celebrating the 21st birthday of Irene Von Helldorf (Gloria Stuart), along with her father, Robert (Lionel Atwill), and her three suitors, Frank Faber (Onslow Stevens), a newspaper reporter; Walter Brink (Paul Lukas), a captain in the military; and Thomas Brandt (William Janney). Brandt, the youngest of the trio, gathers enough courage to ask Irene to marry him, but she doesn't take him seriously. Following an evenings entertaining of Irene singing "I Can't Help But Dream of You" on piano, the howling wind leads to a fright story told by Robert regarding the secret of the blue room. His retelling about the strange enactment that occurred twenty years ago when Irene was a baby, and to why the room had been locked up since then. With Paul, the Butler (Robert Barrat) in charge of its only key, the story begins with the death of Robert's sister, believed to have plunged to her death from the open window; followed four months later by his friend who was mysteriously shot to death with the door locked from inside; then a detective, spending the night in the room, found dead from something that caused his fatal heart attack. Interestingly, all deaths took place exactly at 1 a.m. Hoping to influence Irene he's no weakling, Thomas shows off his courage with hope of marriage by volunteering to spend the night in the blue room, with the other suitors doing the same thing on subsequent nights. With Thomas the first to spend the night there, accompanied by Blink, history starts to repeat itself involving similar circumstances along with a mysterious stranger in the house having attacking Irene. Brink immediately telephones his good friend, Commissioner Forster (Edward Arnold) to come and investigate. Others in the cast include Muriel Kirkland (Belle, the Maid); Russell Hopton (Max, the chauffeur); Elizabeth Patterson (Mary, the housekeeper); Anders Van Haden (The Stranger) and James Durkin (Forster's Assistant).

Resembling that of a film series involving famed movie detectives like Philo Vance or Sherlock Holmes, SECRET OF THE BLUE ROOM contains no interesting camera angles in the James Whale method, nor real gruesome mood music for elements of surprise. Its brief storytelling of 66 minutes is routinely made murder mystery theme more interesting for its familiar cast members than anything else. Lionel Atwill always adds mystery to his character, whether he's guilty or not, while Gloria Stuart, best known for her performance in THE INVISIBLE MAN (1933), offers typical heroine screams in frightful fashion, but not as much as Fay Wray in KING KONG (1933). Though SECRET OF THE BLUE ROOM gets by in formula fashion, its only setback. Involving the secret of the first blue room murders remains a mystery.

Never distributed on video cassette, but available on DVD. SECRET OF THE BLUE ROOM (which ends with a good cast listing worth repeating to "Swan Lake" scoring) did get its rare cable television broadcasting on Turner Classic Movies as part of its Summer Under the Stars tribute to Lionel Atwill in August 3, 2018. For those familiar with Lionel Atwill's other notable 1933 releases of THE VAMPIRE BAT, MURDERS IN THE ZOO and MYSTERY OF THE WAX MUSEUM, and admirers to the "Swan Lake" composition, should find this movie worth viewing as well. (**)
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Very Disappointing
arfdawg-119 July 2021
Was looking forward to streaming this film.

It's Universal, a dark spooky mustery and had some actors I liked.

Many, is it boring. Really slow. I was falling a sleep.

Soooo disappointing.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed