"Smallville" Asylum (TV Episode 2004) Poster

(TV Series)

(2004)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Nasty Lionel Luthor
claudio_carvalho11 May 2006
Lionel Luthor forces the shrink Dr. Claire Foster to submit Lex Luthor to electroshocks to erase his memory and forget his crime. Clark Kent tries to save his friend, but Eric Summers (from "Leech"), Van McNulty (from "Extinction") and Ian Randall (from "Dichotic") plot a plan to attack him and escape from the asylum. Meanwhile, Lana Lang is recovering the movements of her wounded leg with the support of the patient Adam Knight (Ian Somerhalder, the Boone Carlyle from "Lost").

"Asylum" is a great episode of "Smallville", with outstanding performances of John Glover and Michael Rosenbaum. This episode is certainly one of the best of this series, with intense dramatic situations and also lots of action with Clark struggling against two powerful enemies. Lionel Luthor is really a nasty character, especially when he says "-Lex, my son.". My vote is ten.

Title (Brazil): "Sanatório" ("Asylum")
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
What a terrible father Lionel is
Rcwilkinson12314 November 2007
Warning: Spoilers
The father-son rivalry that is Lionel and Lex Luthor hits a dramatic and exciting point in "Asylum." Following Lex's madness in the previous episode "Shattered," Lionel admits Lex to the mental institution Belle Reeve, which largely houses meteor freaks gone mad due to their mutated ability. These meteor-infected include Eric Summers, Ian Randall, and Van, all who have their own personal grudges against Clark, who in reality is largely responsible for their residence there due to previous confrontations with each of them.

At Belle Reeve, during a visit from Clark, Lex lashes out at him to use his secret to get Lex out of the asylum. Clark doesn't confirm or deny Lex's accusation of Clark's secret. Eventually, Lionel despicably tells Lex's psychiatrist to do electroshock therapy on his son, a procedure that wipes seven weeks of memory, but could turn Lex into a vegetable if everything doesn't go perfectly as planned. Clark and Chloe convince the psychiatrist to not do the therapy, but the next day the psychiatrist mysteriously died in a car wreck. Both Clark and Lex find themselves in perilous situations at Belle Reeve before Clark can ward off the vengeful mutants.

This episode illustrates the boundaries that Lionel is wishing to push to erase Lex's investigations of him concerning the death of Lionel's parents. It shows that Lionel truly does not care much for his son, but is more concerned with concealing his past from the world.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
3x09 - Rewatch (Lex-centric episode)
DCSassyQueen21 July 2016
Lex is residing in an asylum because Lionel is keeping him there to hide his dirty laundry. Clark is trying to find a way to prove that Lex is perfectly innocent before they fry his brain.

Pete is getting on nerves & what is his point anyways. Also, Mr. & Mrs. Kent are both annoying as well. I cannot wait until their presence becomes nonexistent

Damon Salvatore has arrived with his fine self.

I love seeing Clark try to prove Lex's innocence because he does not deserve it. Meanwhile, the people who Clark placed in the asylum are trying to team up against him by finding his weakness from Van. The minions succeed, which kind of made me happy because it delayed Lex's vegetation process.

Although I feel sorry for Lex, I feel uncomfortable with him knowing Clark's secret. Poor Lex, though...I just want to throw Lionel off a cliff for putting Lex through so much trauma. I hope that Lex gets back at Lionel for having him placed in an asylum... that man is one crazy assx person.

Why are the writers enforcing the friendship between Clark & Lex? It just makes me sad for their future.

Stop this Clark & Lana madness now !!!!
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Season 3 keeps on giving...
m-478264 August 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Perry and Relic were great stand-alone. One introduced us to a key character and the other, played the retro special card, to tell a compelling story, and bridge the gap between generations. Magnetic was a decent filler where Lana gets wild, again. And Shattered was just keeping you at the edge of your seat, waiting to see this closing scene. With Johnny Cash's chilling cover of that NIN song « hurt ». When Lionel watched Lex in his straitjacket, and Clark lied by Lana's hospital bed. Asylum starts with Massive Attack « future proof », when Lex is at the asylum, before Clark makes a visit, and reunites with his former one time enemies. A young Ian Somerhalder joins the cast, as one guy in Lana's physiotherapy class. But he's clearly more than that. And the rest try to keep their secrets hidden. It's a very good episode that delivers what the Winter finale promised, and suggested the season might become the most addictive to date. There seems to be a big reduction in the music department this season, with less « expensive » songs each episodes. Which probably was a way to prevent all the cuts and changes shows with less restraint encountered on the DVDS and streaming. But to be honest, it changes nothing. Like this episode proves, less is more. And those songs have more impact like that.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Psychiatric hospitalization sensationalism
ejehaley11 March 2019
Overall, interesting episode. It was a great idea to have Clark re-encounter three former classmate-villains from seasons 1 and 2. My main critique is with ho Belle Reeve is portrayed. I worked at a state psychiatric hospital for 10 years, and this episode sensationalizes mental illness and psych hospitals and promotes the stigma against mental illness. Hospitals- * are well-lit and use bright, pleasant colors * do often have beds attached to the floor, but they're cots with mattresses, pillows, and blankets * allow patients to wear their own clothes, within reason * do not look like jails with metal toilets * do not have walls of windows looking into patient rooms * do not use batons, metal cages, padded rooms, and straitjackets anymore, and haven't for a long time * do not allow ROCKS or other weapons on-site * have opportunities to engage in arts and leisure activities, but not in public places * maintain patient confidentiality by having visitors only visit in specific places, not on the units * do not have patient fights on a regular basis, as people with mental illnesses are no more violent than the rest of society

I have this same critique for other episodes of this show. I look forward to the day that TV and movies portray people with mental illnesses accurately and respectfully.
11 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed