I'm Not Ashamed (2016) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
94 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Homage to one of the Columbine victims
paul-allaer22 October 2016
"I'm Not Ashamed" (2016 release; 112 min.) brings the story of 17 yr. old student Rachel Scott, who was the very first victim at the Columbine High School tragedy in 1999. As the movie opens, we get TV footage from those horrifying moments right after the shootings. We then go back in time, when Rachel was 8 years old, and her parents are splitting up, leaving her mom in a financial struggle to raise 5 kids. We then go to "April 1998 - Sophomore Year", with Rachel doing well in school. Rachel is particularly interested in the drama class. At this point we're not even 15 min. into the movie but to tell you more would spoil your viewing experience.

Couple of comments: this movie is marketed as a "christian" film, and plays out like one. If that is going to bother you, please do yourself a favor and catch a different movie for your enjoyment. I really didn't know what to expect and was pleasantly surprised at the maturity, even sophistication, of this movie (the script is based on Rachel's journals, we are reminded at the beginning of the movie). That said, it is also a bit of a missed opportunity, as it focuses mainly on Rachel, and not hardly any time on the 2 shooters. If you have the expectation that this movie might delve into the "why did they do it", this movie will not provide the answer (other than some very general and broad brushes). All that said, the last 15 min. of the movie packs an emotional wallop, for obvious reasons. The movie makers hit the bull's eye when they cast Masey McLain as Rachel, she is absolutely fantastic. Bottom line: this is a fine movie (made on a dime, total budget a mere $1.5 million). But if you want to understand Columbine, this is not the movie for it. (Earlier this year, Sue Klebold, the mother of Dylan, one of the 2 Columbine shooters, issued a devastating memoir called "A Mother's Reckoning: Living in the Aftermath of Tragedy", which I would readily recommend to anyone, Christian or not.)

The movie opened on a couple of screens this weekend here in Cincinnati. The Saturday matinée screening where I saw this at was attended very nicely, somewhat to my surprise. It sounds like there is a market for well-made Christian films. If, on the other hand, you want to get a look at the promising life of one of the Columbine victims (who this year otherwise would be 34 years old), then I would readily recommend you check this out, be it in the theater, on VOD, or eventually on DVD/Blu-ray.
31 out of 64 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
You just wonder why? and their is no answer.....
mellotr26 November 2019
This is a sweet story on one hand, and is a tragedy on the other. It's a story of an ordinary teenage girl experiencing first love, heartbreak and struggling with her faith. The true story of Rachel Scott, is the main focus of the film and its Heartbreaking to say the least. The movie is about Rachel and the person she was, and her faith in God. The shooting is secondary, and is only relevant to the unnecessary, unimaginable loss of potential in each victim. The innocent lives lost affected the world. We don't know the difference they would have made, the accomplishments. I believe through this movie that's what Rachel Scott did; she is still making a difference.
8 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Life. Worth living for something, for some people!
Reno-Rangan13 October 2017
Based on the journal of a person who had got killed in the 1999 shooting at a high school in the US. Really inspiring character and the story, till that final horror event. But the real shame was, the filmmakers used it to promote religious. Or maybe they have highlighted too much from the religious aspect. Because, her life and that horrific event connected with her unexpected prediction which are only a coincident, rather any miracle from heaven. I'm not against believers, but I anticipated honest, a reality, not fantasy.

So coming to the film, apart from misusing a real person's life, it was a nice film. Nice casting and performances. Masey McLain was so pretty and awesome in her role. Don't expect it to be the film about that 1999 shooting. It was not about that, except it had a connection as everything was built behind it. They have shown very little from that angle towards the end. Some of the real footage attached in those parts. Yeah, the end was emotional as expected. Everyone might not find it a good film for what I had told earlier, nevertheless the true story deserves some respect.

6/10
9 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
A slap in the face for anyone affected by a national tragedy...
ethal-106115 August 2018
Why do mass shootings happen? Mental illness? Easy access to firearms for children? Poor life lessons from parents and authority figures? NOPE! According to this movie, they happen because people just don't love Jesus enough. This movie cleverly starts by exploiting actual footage of the Columbine shooting because when you start at rock bottom, there's nowhere to go but up! If you take away anything from this experience, just remember that it's ok to exploit real world tragedies as long as it's for Jesus!
42 out of 74 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Missing the point of the movie
zacharykieler16 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Atheists out there slam this movie because they think this movie is all about Christianity and cashing in on this tragedy. While yes it has Christian overtones. Rachel Scott was a Christian this was her belief and people need to respect her religion. For Atheists to slam this movie proves they don't get the point to this movie. Recently I watched a Anne Frank documentary at the beginning the director of the talks about Anne which directly Applies to Rachel Scott "The World will never know who was lost or what was lost when these kids were murdered there future was shut down for them but if we imagine what we lost we might belong with those who directly experienced this event more deeply and more humbly" Rachel Scott was a beautiful human being, if everybody was like her the world would be a much better place may she RIP.
70 out of 125 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Very Touching
gidgetpink-8364122 February 2018
I don't consider this a Christian movie, it's a movie about Rachel and her experiences at Columbine during the last year of her life. I'm not sure why people are discrediting the movie. Richard Castaldo was shot only inches away from Rachel, he told the press that Eric asked her about her belief in God before he shot her. Also, the basement tapes showcase Eric and Dylan's disdain for Jesus and Christianity.....and life. The movie shows the difficult environment these columbine students had to navigate daily, it's worth a watch.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Watchable
dar041713 February 2020
Taking something very tragic and turning it into some inspiring made this film watchable.
8 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Manipulative
masoncheek5 May 2020
This film makes it seem like the shooters went straight for the Christians and that's why they shot up the school. This is not historically accurate and it manipulates and exploits the death of Rachel as a way to push a message. By the way, I'm a Christian and I still think this movie sucks.
30 out of 51 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Maybe the Best Christian Film
bkrauser-81-31106427 October 2016
I'm Not Ashamed is based on the life and premature death of Rachel Joy Scott, a student who went to Columbine High School on the fateful day Dylan Klebold and Eric Harris committed, what was at the time the worst school shooting in U.S. history. The film is brought to you by Pure Flix Entertainment, an independent Christian film and television studio which should give you an indication of who this movie is for and what it's trying to accomplish. Given my particular track-record with this production company, I came in fully expecting to hate this film - especially given its uncomfortable subject matter. Yet by the time the film reached its inevitable, heartbreaking conclusion, I must admit, this little Christian title had me a bit misty-eyed.

The film begins with a young Rachel drawing on her wardrobe cabinet with Crayon. We're given a brief tour of her broken home before she's whisked away as a teen to Louisiana for the summer to stay with her aunt (under the pretense of avoiding negative influences). It is in Louisiana she rediscovers Christ, starting her sophomore year at Columbine as a baby born again with a necklace cross to prove it. Yet as she rejoins her friends she soon recognizes the struggle of being disciplined in a school culture dominated by teenage angst, blossoming libidos and weekend partying.

Is I'm Not Ashamed Ham-fisted; yeah, pompous and overbearing; sure, amateurish in its execution; you bet, but the story, partially taken from Rachel's diary has a ring of truth to it. We're put into her head-space and can empathize with her struggles to fit in while staying true to her values, finding humility in ourselves as she stumbles, falls and gets up again learning as she goes. For once I felt like I was watching a movie about a Christian instead of a Christian movie. It never feels like a lecture or a sermon but rather a case for understanding; a peek into a worldview through a coming-of-age tale.

The story is served stupendously by the young Masey McLain who doesn't so much debut as arrives to the medium announcing she's the genuine article. She easily sidesteps the stodgy staging, internalizes the poorly delivered lines of her counterparts and reacts like everything is designed for her. That's no easy feat when you have a movie that has her pulling a manic pixie girl routine for a homeless man (Davies) with poorly designed tribal tattoos and the haircut of a 1960's NASA employee.

Additionally, the very rudimentary direction and cinematography can't help but undercut the film at every turn. There wasn't a single inspired moment. Of course an argument can be made that I'm Not Ashamed purposely eschews the Norman Rockwell sheen of Miracles from Heaven (2016) or Heaven is For Real (2014) to give it a certain authenticity. Yet I'd be more receptive to that idea if it wasn't so obvious they were trying for it. At it's best the film has the poorly executed sweep of a below average music video complete with scenes of the least exciting teenage ragers in history. At its worst I'm Not Ashamed resembles a Valtrex commercial.

A lot can be said about producer David A.R. White and Pure Flix's unabashed cavort towards Christ-ploitation but at least there's little doubt they actually believe what they're selling. I'd be lying if I said I didn't pruriently enjoy the flippant potshots towards groups not attune to the film's values - in this case the silliest analog is Cameron McKendry as a crush who "doesn't want to use labels". At this point, the kind of culture war contrarianism this kind of stuff is known for should be reacted to with a roll of the eyes.

Yet when all is said and done, Rachel's initial message of compassion and kindness shines through the usual muck and noise. While yes, it might be just as shabby looking as your average 7th Heaven (1996- 2007) riff, the familiar wrapping shouldn't necessarily dissuade. For once we're treated to a grown up, Christian worldview that proudly states what it's about instead of quibbling over what it's against. Considering that almost never happens, I'm Not Ashamed is arguably the best Christian film made yet.

And yes I did chuckle during the credits when, once again, we were zealously given the number to the film's text campaign.
19 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Agenda driven movie is obvious.
Java_Joe6 June 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Here's the thing, what happened at Columbine was a tragedy. And it was inevitable that somebody would come along and try to make a movie about it. The problem is instead of focusing on the events that took place and led up to the shooting we're instead shown the life of a young girl who was killed in the tragedy.

That all by itself wouldn't necessarily be a bad thing as part of this is based on her diary and what her friends said of her. They even go as far as to portray her as a normal teen who sneaks out of her house to have some fun with her friends and have her drink and smoke.

But they really played up the religious angle which would be fine if it actually had anything to do with the story. The idea is that the killers supposedly asked her before she was shot if she believed in God and when she said yes, they said, "go be with him" and shot her. The problem is, nobody else was around to have heard her say this. All this story is building up to her, when being faced with death, saying she believes in God knowing it would mean her death.

And yet the killers also seemed to go after those that weren't believers. This is why I say this movie has an obvious agenda. And honestly I wouldn't mind so much. Religious movies are a big thing in today's world. The problem is when they decide to play fast and loose with the facts or reality in an attempt to sell their story.
42 out of 77 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Well Done! Recommend This for Schools and Youth Groups
claireb-7835715 February 2017
How fortunate that Rachel Scott's diary was found in order to have a view into one of the lives lost at Columbine. It must have been heartwrenching for her family and friends to see this on the "big screen," but perhaps it provides a way for them to honor her life and help to continue the healing process.

Because the subject matter is so disturbing, I do agree with a PG-13 rating. That being said, I also believe this movie should be shared with every youth group. It would also be beneficial as part of schools' "anti-bullying" programs.

Each person impacted by Columbine has their own unique story. The struggles and questions faced by Rachel were well portrayed. The actors who were cast as Rachel and Nathan did an excellent job. Very believable.

This movie showed how kindness, compassion, and forgiveness can change hearts and lives. Rachel's brief life continues to have ripple effects nearly 20 years later. The Lord truly must have welcomed Rachel into heaven with "Well done, good and faithful servant" and continues to use her life to point people to Him.
35 out of 63 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
an inspiring and tragic story, with appeal beyond the Christian community
dave-mcclain24 October 2016
On April 20, 1999, in Littleton, Colorado, two Columbine High School students, seniors Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, murdered 12 students and 1 teacher at their school and injured 21 others in the deadliest U.S. school shooting to date. The first of the students killed was 17-year-old senior Rachel Scott, who was eating lunch with a fellow student just outside the school. The film "I'm Not Ashamed" (PG-13, 1:52) is Rachel's story. The script by Philipa Booyens, Robin Hanley, Kari Redmond and Bodie Thoene doesn't shy away from the buildup to the shooting, but this isn't primarily a story of tragedy. It's a story of faith.

In most ways, Rachel Joy Scott (Masey McLain) was a typical high school girl. She had supportive friends, but she was insecure. She was attracted to one of her classmates, but lacked the confidence to pursue her crush. She had struggles at home and sometimes did things that got her in trouble with her parents, but she wasn't really a "bad" kid. She had hopes and dreams, but couldn't see what life had in store. And she kept a journal, which forms the basis for the narrative of this film, plus first-hand accounts about Rachel's life and the circumstances surrounding her death… only weeks before she would have graduated. (Note: Rachel isn't the Columbine victim who was the subject of the book "She Said Yes".) As the film opens, Rachel's divorced mother, Beth (Terri Minton), is having trouble supporting herself and her five kids. (Rachel is the middle child.) Beth eventually remarries, but she and her new husband, Larry (John Newberg), have problems steering Rachel toward making positive choices in her young life, as when Rachel sneaks out at night to attend parties with her friends (Victoria Staley, Taylor Kalupa and Emma Elle Roberts). Rachel is being raised in a household of strong Christian faith, but doesn't really embrace that faith until after spending the summer before her senior year with family in Louisiana.

Even when she makes her family's faith her own, she struggles to live according to the Bible. She seems more concerned about pursuing a romantic relationship with Alex (Cameron McKendry), the BMOC in her drama class, and she shies away from discussing her increasing faith with him. Eventually, her commitment to Christ strengthens to the point that it drives a wedge between her and her closest friends. Yet, she still continues seeking, learning, growing in her faith, and finding ways to live out that faith, such as when she determinedly befriends and helps a homeless teen named Nathan (Ben Davies).

As Rachel's story unfolds, two of her classmates, Eric Harris (David Errigo, Jr.) and Dylan Klebold (Cory Chapman) bond over their shared hatred for high school culture and the world in general. With Harris taking the lead, the two teens begin discussing acting out their frustrations through violence and plan what became the Columbine Massacre. As their story careens toward its tragic collision with Rachel's, the focus stays on Rachel's spiritual journey and director Brian Baugh handles Rachel's final moments tastefully and with compassion (although he does take some liberties with a few of the factual details).

This is an inspiring and tragic story, with appeal beyond the Christian community. The Columbine Massacre is an event of ongoing interest and relevance, so there's understandable interest in a film set against that backdrop. This movie stays just this side of exploitation, but does indulge in a few brief moments of melodrama. The story of Rachel and her classmates is engagingly and realistically told and generally well acted. However, regardless of your personal religious beliefs (or lack thereof), Rachel's struggles with issues of faith and personal conduct should be relatable to most Movie Fans, and Rachel makes for a very sympathetic character. With built-in drama and universal themes, "I'm Not Ashamed" rises above most faith-based films in both appeal and quality. "B+"
18 out of 46 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Exploitive, Disgusting, Unoriginal, Piece of Trash, Makes Karla decent by comparison.
Payback101627 August 2022
Warning: Spoilers
First and foremost, I am not slamming this movie for it being a movie about Columbine. Like many tragedies before and after, a movie was bound to be made about it. The only Praise I would give this, is that it's one of the few movies out there that tries to do it in the point of view of the victim rather than the killer, but that's the only praise I am giving it.

I have never ever seen a biopic movie horrifically bad since the Karla Homolka biopic starring Laura Prepon. You people managed to finally do it and make a movie about Karla Homolka, another exploitive POS biopic that paints a criminal mastermind as one of Bernardo's victims, look decent by comparison.

First let's get this out of the way. The movie's aesop seems to convey that Christianity is the way to go and that people like Eric and Dylan are evil Atheists that don't believe in God. I've looked the actual tragedy up, in no way shape or form was the shootings religiously motivated. Yet here they are shooting Christians only instead of I don't know everyone they could aim their guns at.

Second, at first I felt bad for the families of the victims as well as the parents of the killers being exploited by these people. Only for me to find out later that not only was this based off a book by the victim's mother, but she served as Executive Producer of this POS movie. That means she paid money and had say in what goes on in the movie. She could have told the truth and put more emphasis on Rachel's diaries, but instead, she twists the words and makes her daughter into a martyr all so she can profit off it and spread her overtly Christian agenda. She even went so far as to go on the 700 club, exploiting her daughter's death to get them donations. I'm sorry, but she gets no sympathy from me.

I never even heard of this movie until today and now that I seen it I wish I didn't. If you don't want to see an example of how scummy the human race can be, then don't watch this, because it's too real of an example.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
The 13 Reasons Why of Christian cinema
Galop_Inferno28 April 2023
If it weren't Pure Flix, using a natural tragedy for clout or leading us into thinking Rachel was shot due to her faith (she happened to be the first person they saw), I might actually rate this higher but I can't in all good consciousness. I'm waiting for these fools to clout chase 9/11. They'd do it. I just want to know how many characters outside of the victims were created by the FOUR sick writers. They should be beaten with an oar.

For what little it's worth, the acting is good but everything else - the writing, direction, cinematography and awful "uplifting" soundtrack - is so laughable, it can't be taken seriously. The title card gave me 13 Reasons Why vibes, and ultimately the whole thing reeks of that show.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Don't miss this one!
cjase2200713 March 2017
This movie was very well done. Great story and the fact that it is a true story makes it much better. It brought me back to my high school days. Rachel was a great soul who helped everyone who came in her path. I don't understand the controversy or how some say it was exploited. This is her story and she was a Christian. That's all. In her own words, "Love and compassion can start a chain reaction." Highly recommended.
39 out of 72 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Absolute gem.
housebeast15 June 2019
Even though the target audience is very limited, this movie will work with anyone who genuinely wants to watch it. It's very inspirational, promotes forgiveness and compassion. It's not a hard watch, with the setting being very relatable and the personal growth message, this movie wont be easy to forget. And those 2 things are the most shiny things you will find in this movie. The level of inspirational content this movie has, it's not easy to find in another popular movie this days. Personally I didn't know a thing about Rachel, but with this movie I get how important she became to all the people who felt her presence in their lives. She was love itself, and definitively wanted you to become love to other's too. if you feel watching this, don't miss it please. And if you cassually want to show this to a youth group or family, it's a must-watch!
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Meh I mean... annoying really.
nichschwabee-2665917 July 2018
Having been in high school myself in 1999 & around that same time also became a born again Christian I was open to being rieceptive to what non-religious people might roll their eyes at. But... this... actually painful to watch. The overly dramatic "i'm so persecuted, life is so so hard & no one could ever understand how bad I've got it" got old real fast. Rachel could have been much more relatable & sympathetic had she not been portrayed (hopefully inaccurately) as a self absorbed over the top angsty one-dimensional person. It actually made me feel LESS sympathetic towards her & was just plain annoying. If that was me being portrayed as such I'd be embarrassed honestly. Making someone come across as a saint (despite her "sins" that she always seems to feel entirely too guilty for ) doesn't envoke even the slightest form of interest or feeling from me. Was quite disappointing & cliche. Cmon it's not like she was nailed to a cross & tormented to death here plus she wasn't even the only one who was supposedly killed based on her religion or even the only person according to witnesses who was asked about their faith. I mean i'm sure she was a sweetheart & truly only wanted to do good with her life & lead others to the Lord but this wasn't shown in the best light. If i ever give it another watch it'll be for the laughs from all the melodrama.
13 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Knowledge of what you are commenting on is required.
gregg-mail31 January 2017
All the people giving this movie a bad review, because it either didn't address the reasons for the Columbine killings or that it expressed Christian beliefs, are narrow-minded myopic people, who don't even have enough mental capacity to understand that the movie was not about the Columbine shooting.

This is a most excellent movie if you want an accurate portrayal of the contents of a high school girl's diary. This is not a movie about the Columbine shootings. It is a movie about the struggles of a high school girl who became a Christian her junior year and the internal struggles that she went through as written in her diary. It does show how her life ended, but that was just just the conclusion of an accurate portrayal of her diary. If the movie is approached with this focus in mind, and not an expectation of a focus on Columbine, then this movie will move you to tears.
49 out of 93 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
About the first victim of the Columbine massacre, a positive legacy worth knowing
jacobs-greenwood4 October 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I knew nothing of Rachel Joy Scott until I happened upon this movie, a Netflix recommendation in the Faith & Spirituality category. I have to admit that my initial impression - after watching the first 10 minutes - had nothing to do with the story; the quality of the production and acting distracted me. Not that either are bad, but neither are on par with higher budget films. However, I was soon engrossed in the narrative, which is compelling not just because it's true. If you're open to it, Rachel's story will bring tears to your eyes on more than one occasion, though perhaps not as many as it should. I finally realized that it is the direction - by cinematographer Brian Baugh, an inexperienced director - that's likely the culprit for why I'm Not Ashamed (2016) didn't have the emotional impact that it could have, at least for me.

Masey McLain plays Rachel, a young girl who struggled with her Christianity especially given that her dad (a former pastor, which the movie doesn't reveal) divorced her mother Beth (Terri Minton) when she was 7. Beth had to raise Rachel and her four siblings as a single mother for seven years. Before her mother remarried, Rachel recommitted her life to Jesus while visiting her aunt and cousin (Korie and Sadie Robertson of Duck Dynasty fame) in Louisiana.

Being more outspoken about her beliefs cost Rachel some of her closest friends, but even while knowing it was worth it, she struggled with a teenager's need to be accepted in high school. While some of the story's elements have been changed or fictionalized, the vast majority of it appears to be true according to my research. The character of Nathan 'Nate' Ballard (Ben Davies), a homeless young man that Rachel 'adopts' as her bigger brother - helping him to find Jesus, actually has a different real name.

Most of the film's run-time (just under 2 hours) focuses on Rachel's junior year at Columbine, which ended on April 20, 1999 when Eric Harris (David Errigo Jr.) and Dylan Klebold (Cory Chapman) murdered her and 12 others at the Colorado high school before both committed suicide. Rachel was involved in art and drama. Cameron McKendry plays Alex, who played opposite Rachel in a play. This led the two of them into a relationship that Rachel ended when she feared it might become physical.

Apparently Rachel positively impacted a lot of people through her Christ-following example, some that she was aware of in life and others that she likely didn't know about. While the film does depict the fact that many students decorated her abandoned red Acura with flowers and letters - making it a shrine, it doesn't show her funeral, which was attended by more than 1,000 people; its live television broadcast audience exceeded that of Princess Diana's.

The epilogue does state that Rachel's story has touched millions of lives, but doesn't mention that this is due in large part to family members that wrote books and, most importantly, started Rachel's Challenge, whose objectives are to: help schools and businesses become safer, more connected places to live and learn; stimulate real culture change by actively involving the entire community in the process; change lives by providing culturally relevant social/emotional training; and increase achievement and ensure results by engaging the participants' heart, head and hands in a continuing improvement process.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
I'm not ashamed to admit that this Pure Flix film was not as bad, as some critics make it out to be. Even with its flaws, the movie decent enough to watch.
ironhorse_iv7 December 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Anybody that knows me, knows, that I'm not a huge fan of independent faith-based movies; especially from Pure Flix Entertainment. Yet, there are a few movies out, there; I have no problem with. 2016's 'I'm Not Ashamed' is one of those. Directed by Brian Baugh & somewhat based on the journal of real-life student, Rachel Joy Scott, this movie accounts Scott (Masey McLain)'s journey as she struggles of keeping her faith, during her troubling last year at Columbine High School. Without spoiling the movie, too much, while, the trailers might make it seem, like the filmmakers are seemingly using a real-life tragedy like the 1999's Columbine Shooting to promote a stereotypical Christian agenda, as if the whole event was cause by religious persecution. That's really far from the case, once you see the movie, as the movie takes a complex approach to the controversial issues of bulling, showing that, anybody could fall victim to it, Christian or not. While, it's true, that there was still some scenes of her regularly being subjected to mockery, due to her belief to God. Christianity is not really, not the main focus. It's more about her, trying to show compassion than preaching to the choir, when, face with indifferentism. It's also a movie about learning how to sympathy with the people, instead of trying to over-demonize them for actions, you don't believe with. This was something, very rare to see in a Pure Flix movie, whom films like 2014's 'Old Fashioned' & 2014's 'God's Not Dead', are known for being a little too righteous for its own good. Another good thing about this movie is that, the film doesn't make Rachel, out to be, too much of an angelic figure that nobody can related. She still has problems, most teens deal with; whether it's the fear, her not succumbing to much, after high school, her off and on, relationships with lovers, friends and family, her problems with alcohol & weed smoking, or her dealing with suicidal thoughts. It's character development 101. Regardless, I do think, the movie could had cut down on a bit, on the subplot of a love triangle, brewing between her & two boys, Alex Dickerson (Cameron McKendry) & fictional Nathan Ballard, loosely based on, Mark Bodiford-Pettit, as it was going too much into 2008's 'Twilight' fan-fiction, when in truth, while, Scott was somewhat popular, she mostly kept to herself, only, having one serious relationship, before breaking it up, herself, not because of her partner cheating on her, but because she didn't want it to become physical demanding, as she was moving out on her own, with a friend, Alisha Basore after high school. Another thing, misleading, was the idea, that she attended prom with a minor, fictional Asian character, named Kevin (Mark Daugherty). In real life, she went with Nick Baumgart, another Caucasian, student & one of the main targets, for the shooter. Another big misinformation that the movie is trying to spread is the idea that the shooters, Eric Harris (David Errigo Jr.) & Dylan Klebold (Cory Chapman) ask Scott, before killing her, if she believe in God. Based on the many of police reports, I have research & testimony of students around her, at the crime scene, I can personally, say, this, probably never really happen; as in real-life, Rachel was hit four times and was killed instantly. Survivor Valeen Schnurr claims that she was the one questioned as to her belief in God by the shooters & her statements were misdirection by news medias at the time, causing people to believe that the questions were direction to Scott & another victim, Cassie Bernall. Nevertheless, both victims came to be regarded as Christian martyrs by Evangelical Christians, overtime. Because of that, the movie does feel, a bit over-sentimental at times with the symbolism God's light visuals from cinematographer John Matysiak and cheesy Christian music by composer, Timothy William that went along with Scott, at certain points of the film. As for the murderers, I kinda, glad the movie didn't focus, too much on them. While, it's true, that information would help the film, a little more, on understanding, their motives. I really don't think, they really need, any more spotlight. The movie alright went overboard with the foreshadowing to the shooting. In my opinion, their presence should had been even cut, even shorter, as their climatic action would be more shocking. Nevertheless, the movie did right, with not showing anymore of the shooting, after her death, but archive news footage. The abrupt ending had still had enough of an impact to make me, feel a bit, emotional. Nevertheless, the film could had been a little more gritty with the language for a PG-13. Overall: I have to say, the movie was very insightful with its' semi-alright, acting and production values. Still, I can understand, why certain people might hate this movie for even existence. I was kinda turn off, by it, at first. After all, Columbine High School massacre is still, a fresh open wound to some people. In the end, I change my mine, because talking about the event, is the best way to heal. I just wish, the movie wasn't made, to make a profit for the studio-heads. In short, the box office take, should had gone to the victim's families, charities, or preventing gun-violence. Not the big wigs in Hollywood. In the end, while, the movie isn't God-awful. It's should had been a little more well-made. The victims of this tragedy, deserve better.
8 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Good movie based on Rachel's journals
castle23-189-2661316 February 2017
I am not really a church goer but it is very interesting the adverse reaction some have to Christianity in a movie. It's like that reaction vampires have in movies to the cross or holy water. I found the movie enjoyable and inspiration yet so tragic. My daughter could relate to similar struggles in school and the dynamics. What seems evil (or dysfunctional if you would like to use a secular term) is that individuals like Rachel are the "fascists" in the world we live in, whereas groups like Antifa at Berkeley are the new solution. The movie does have some drinking and smoking in it and some sexual situations but nothing R rated. I would watch this with a teen, it may be a bit much for a ten year old depending on your viewpoints.
38 out of 71 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
did she befriended a disabled kid in real life.
ozanarslantas101124 May 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Rachel was acted like an angel in this movie. I wish there many of like her in the world. what a trajedy.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Plays out like a lame Lifetime Afterschool special
SusieSalmonLikeTheFish8 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I don't agree with the reviewers who say that this film is exploiting the tragedy of the Columbine shooting, in fact all it's doing is raising awareness of what happened - but they could've been more authentic and serious about it. I went into this expecting a good film and it turned out to be like a bad Lifetime movie. This was supposed to take place in the 1990's, but aside from the absence of technology there is absolutely nothing 'nineties' about it. Rachael looks like she should have a cellular phone in her hands. The yoga pants and super-straight hair and half-shirts are all 21st century ugly fashions, the way the characters spoke sounded like social media posts... why? How hard is it to create a nineties vibe? Even just a few popular 1990's music hits or a VHS tape of something could've really improved this.

And what's with the super-religious themes? There is one particularly odd scene of Rachael in church, screaming and crying while music plays, shouting about Jesus for no reason. She wears a giant wooden cross around her neck. When her parents' finances go bad, her mom and siblings stand in a circle, holding hands and speaking aloud to God. Is this realistic? Was Racheal's family really like that to the extent that this film portrays? The lines were horrible. Rachael talking in a cutesy voice, saying, "c'mon, Larry, I need my cherry"? Why? I really just don't get it. Is there something special I'm missing here? This film was a complete waste of time and a ridiculous portrayal of a situation that could've been handled on film so much better than this. It seems almost disrespectful, because this film is so lame that it's comedic, and I just didn't understand why the filmmakers would want to create it like this.
17 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Rachel Joy Scott 1981-1999 RIP
bkoganbing8 December 2018
Let me start by saying the death of anyone at the age of 18 is by definition a tragedy. Rachel Scott who was a committed Christian never got a chance to put her life and beliefs into a wider world. Who knows what a longer life experience might have made of her. Masey Mclain gives a most touching performance as Rachel, the first person killed in the Columbine High School massacre of 1999.

The larger issues of why such weaponry got in the hands of these two disturbed individuals Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold is totally ignored. We see a bit of what turned them into what they became, bullied kids who finally just snapped. I read with fascination the fact that a line was omitted from one of these characters where he admits to being gay and he's afraid of winding up like Matthew Shepard. As this is a Christian film it sure wouldn't do to admit homophobia might cause a person to snap.

The story of Rachel Scott is what is concentrated on in I Am Not Ashamed. But who knows if there had been less of a bullying atmosphere and no easy access to weaponry that tragedies like Columbine might not happen.

Hopefully a more intellectually honest film will come along and do just that.
12 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Inspiring and Encouraging!
barbourjohn-633-60893219 March 2017
Where were you when Columbine happened? I remember it well. I was at science camp (Lake Hume, CA) with about 20 of my Middle school students in the cafeteria surrounded by hundreds of other students and faculty from all over California. Needless to say, the whole place sobered up in a hurry.

But little did I know that it would take 18 years for me to realize the true significance of that event. That realization came when I watched this movie. The story of Rachel Scott is an amazing testimony of how God can take a horrific event and use it to reach millions of people with the gospel. It is interesting to note that her life has touched 22 million people; exactly twice as many as Hitler killed. Watch the movie to see the contrast between Hitler's and therefore Eric and Dylan's idea and Jesus and Rachel's idea of making the world a better place.

It is also an amazing testimony of how God prepared Rachel for the way she would glorify Him. Friends, He is doing this with all of us who follow him. If you want a film that inspires and encourages you; you can't do much better than this one.

I highly recommend this movie as one of the best Christian movies out there. The divide you see between the critics and the general audience is telling. Many of us have learned to discount the critics through the years realizing that they cannot be trusted to give a proper assessment. Also, this story is itself an example of how the secular media gets it so wrong most of the time simply because they have no spiritual discernment and work for bosses that are often hostile to the Christian worldview.

On a technical note: In my opinion, this movie is another example of how Christian movies are getting better and better.
35 out of 66 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed