"SEAL Team" Rock Bottom (TV Episode 2019) Poster

(TV Series)

(2019)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Entertaining...lack of facts and procedures notwithstanding.
insideout0983 May 2019
I honestly don't know why these writers don't get the facts straight about military procedures or history. I assume it has to do with either artistic license or some hidden narrative. Either way, I do find the show entertaining for the most part, even with the endless soap operas. These men and women know what they're in for when they become SEALS, so all this back and forth with loved ones is, again, indicative of a show balanced between loose military procedures and an emotional element. Personally, I'd prefer to keep all the personal stuff out of it and just focus on realistic SEAL ops and the people who provide digital oversight.
4 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Nope again Accuracy 0
dncorp2 May 2019
The date we (U.S. Army Special Forces attached to the CIA) attempted kill Osama Bin Laden was 1996 as a Violation of the U.S. No Assassination Policy that would not be changed "amended" to allow the Assassination of Osama Bin Laden until Republican President Bush 2002 Amended U.S. No Assignation Policy (International Agreements). We missed Osama Bin Laden by less than 5 minutes with a missile Strike that would kill about 400 Al Quada Men, Women and too many Children.

Commissioning Ceremony, each Newly Commissioned "Ensign" did not do something Traditional, as giving the first Person that saluted them something (All U.S. Military Officers Know what that "something" is), and does not matter which Branch of Service. All U.S. Military O-1's give the First Person that saluted them that.

At Afghanistan right next door to Pakistan is a Joint U.S. Intelligence Agencies and U.S. Army Special Forces Base. Would take the U.S. Navy S.E.A.L.s from CONUS over 20 Hours to get to Pakistan, India, would take the Fully Qualified U.S. Army Special Forces Teams, ODAs, ODBs attached to the C.I.A. about 2 hours to do Mission Preparations and Deploy. By the time Bravo Team gets to India, Pakistan, the situation would have changed a lot 20 hours later.

Facing a Court Martial for taking things outside to the News Media, Nope, not when pertains to a deceased U.S. Military Service Member, only need a Surviving Relative's Approval to release "Personal Information".

C.I.A. is there or goes there first, C.I.A. S.A.D. and or S.O.G. (Level 1, aka Tier 1) with Us (Joint Services Special Warfare, Level 2 aka Tier 2) attached are "The Tip of The Spear" as unlike Direct Action Teams of U.S. Army Special Forces Operational Detachment 1, and U.S. Navy Special Warfare Development Group as Level 3 aka "Tier 3", we (Level 2 aka Tier 2) actually speak the languages required and know the culture to do successful covert Operations, Missions. Most of Us have been at the Mission, Operation Areas before even training with those Nations Military Forces.

Linking arms together like some kind of Air Show Parachute Demonstration defeats the Purpose of a High Altitude Low Opening (H.A.L.O.) insertion, as becoming detectable by Radar.

India's state of the art technology Russian Federation Air Defenses (same as Iran's that detected the U.S. Generation 5 Stealth RQ-170) would have detected the C-130 and shot the C-130 down as "Shoot First, No Questions will be asked later".

Any tension within a Special Warfare Team, the Commanding Officer has NO Choice and must dissolve the Team immediately, especially if occurs at a Civilian "Establishment" (Bar, Club).

Scriptwriter Michael Watkins is clueless, Grade F (Failure).
7 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Another mistake that could have been avoided
bill-21581 April 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Davis is in Newport, Rhode Island attending Officer Candidate School. At her graduation from OCS, they very clearly pan the hull of BB61, the decommissioned battleship U. S. S. Iowa. The Iowa is now a museum ship in Los Angeles, California. Anyone here really believe they would fly a whole graduating class to Los Angeles for the ceremony?

The crew went our of their way to show us the ceremony took place on the Iowa. Thanks for another insult to our intelligence!

The attention to detail and accuracy, as usual, is terrible.
0 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed