"Mannix" The Girl Who Came in with the Tide (TV Episode 1969) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
LADY IN THE LAKE, MANNIX STYLE.
tcchelsey11 February 2023
Not that bad of a story, and rather scenic, written by producer Ben Roberts and Don Mankewicz, famous for the iconic film, I WANT TO LIVE (1958). Producer Ivan Goff also worked with Roberts, but not on this episode. They were a famous writing team.

Here, Joe suspects that an old "frenemy" is responsible for the death of a young woman whose body washes up on a beach in Malibu. Mannix relies more on hunches here and has some good luck, which is rare. But we'll take it as it comes.

Imposing Lloyd Bochner plays Alec, number one suspect and a thorn in Joe's side. Bochner is quite good here. Beautiful Nancy Kovack play Brett, who again would appear on the series.

This marks the first appearance of Robert Reed as Tobias, who would alternate with Ward Wood as top cop. The story goes that Reed was never happy playing the dad on THE BRADY BUNCH, so producers offered him a side gig . However, when he eventually quit the Brady Bunch, he was also dropped from MANNIX. Personally, I always thought Ward Wood looked the part, and Reed was more typecast.

Partly filmed at sunsational Paradise Cove, located beneath the cliffs at Malibu. This is a public slash private beach, though popular for filming. It's the kind of place you don't want to leave, but it is costly to hang out there.

Worth a look, and especially for Nancy Kovack. SEASON 2 EPISODE 17 remastered CBS box set.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not the best
Guad4218 November 2020
Warning: Spoilers
A woman washes up on the beach and this leads to Mannix investigating the lawyer who had his license pulled for six months. Joe is sure the man is guilty of one murder and, later, of another murder plus an attempted murder. Joe turns out to be smarter than police labs, investigators, and all the evidence compiled by by both. Lloyd Bochner, slick as always, is good at playing the polished but slimy character and he does well here. Nancy Kovacks is simply beautiful and quite fine as the wife of victim #2. Gail Fisher is still making it happen as Peggy. Joe wears an apache tie in the first couple of scenes. Not good. Stick with the classic suit and tie look rather than passing fashions suited for younger people. Robert Reed's first appearance as Joe's police contact. Like the Larry Linville police character, Reed is a sergeant in this first show but a lieutenant in all other shows. Apparently, the police dept has a policy of 'one case with Joe' and 'up you go' on the promotion ladder. The show is weak because Joe goes with his gut and makes a big deal out of it and turns out to be right. Reminds me of the first season and his hatred of computers. Nobody likes a know-it-all who isn't smart enough to stay with Nancy Kovacks.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A bit weak
planktonrules10 July 2013
Warning: Spoilers
The show begins with a woman's body washing up on the coast. A bit later, Mannix is at the morgue looking at the bodies for some case and notices the corpse that washed ashore is familiar--it's the girlfriend of a lawyer Mannix has reason to hate. And, since Mannix would LOVE to see this lawyer (Lloyd Bochner) get hurt, he decides to investigate further. Unfortunately, Mannix's judgment is so impaired because of this, he seems unwilling to consider any alternative--and both Peggy and Sgt. Tobias (Robert Reed) think he is too involved to be objective. After all, Bret Nichols (Nancy Kovack) could also be the one who is responsible for this death and Mannix hasn't even questioned her. So who is at fault for this death...as well as one other than soon is discovered? And, is it true that for once Joe Mannix is totally off base?

Overall, this is only a fair episode mostly because of Mannix's lack of objectivity. This ONLY would have worked had the lawyer been innocent--otherwise it just makes Mannix a know-it-all Mr. Smarty-pants. It also features hunches and gut feelings as opposed to good old fashioned investigating. As a result, the who is a bit weak.
5 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed