"The Outer Limits" Lithia (TV Episode 1998) Poster

(TV Series)

(1998)

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Unintentionally hypocritical throughout?
james_r_webster13 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
On the one hand the sci fi aspect of this episode is relatively believable and the core concept of this episode is interesting, I just think it tries to push the anti man argument too far and contradicts it's message of men being the violent ones throughout.

Plenty of instances in this episode where women threaten violence, use violence and steal. Yet the entire episode Hera the leader of the enclave is berating Major Mercer on being guilty of being a man the most heinous of crimes.

Pele threatens to kill Mercer for sleeping with Miranda. (Threat of violence)

Hyacinth enclave repairs the damn stealing water needed to power the Lithia enclave. (Stealing power)

Ruling council increase taxes by huge margins (Stealing food)

Miranda shoots and kills a member of Hyacinth enclave, member of Hyacinth enclave shoots Mercer off the transformer and he falls to ground. (Violence)

Mercer was the initial cause of some of these, but Pele would just as likely threaten another woman who was sleeping with Miranda. The violence due to stealing power from Hyacinth enclave was avoidable but still women chose to be violent in those circumstances too!?

Major Mercer is really a terrible man (that's totally intentional for the episode though), he's aggressive, immoral and pretty incompetent (especially during the hostage swap incident). For a military man it's pretty amazing how bad he is at combat in stressful situations, he shoots a hostage in the back and manages to shoot Miranda as she's running towards them. But this all serves the primary narrative of the episode, that women would be better off without men.

The missed opportunity here is to give a less bigoted view, had the male who was revived been more of a decent man it would have made for a more interesting story, instead we are given every cliche with Mercer. Whilst we are shown that women can be violent the suggestion is that it's all because of Mercer too, which is unacceptable as a premise.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Man Alive!
Hitchcoc31 May 2014
A community of women has survived a major world war. During that time, the remarkable result is that something has happened to all the men. They have died off. Because of medical technology, the women have been able to produce without mates. There are several of these sects that are governed by a woman who is a kind of overseer to them. Lo and behold a man who has been a cryonic cell wakes up to this world. He finds his way to the commune and is taken care of by them. They are, however, suspicious of his motives, and are constantly on the alert. As time goes on, he begins to aid them in their efforts to produce food. He also begins to have relationships with a couple of the women who welcome it. Problems begin to occur when he suggests that they begin to stand up to the other sects, who have much more than they do. There are some lessons to be learned here about equality and about what a society should be. An interesting, though far fetched effort.
8 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Men are so fragile: its a TV show guys
mbritton177614 June 2023
I laugh and laugh at how bent out of shape and angry men get if a movie or scifi tv show happens to imagine a world without men or with women in power. Why does it anger them so?? Men are still in power and the world is a mess, why can't a few fictional programs imagine a world where men aren't in power? David Keith is likable and you understand his motives, he is not a caricature like so many depictions of ditsy, dumb women. I thought it was an interesting and even humorous episode. Lighten up guys, 99% of media is for the male gaze, but your power must be illusory or slipping if a little fictional television show episode gets you so hot and bothered. I'm not talking about just the reviews here, on youtube when movie reviewers occasionally discuss women ruling over men movies the comments are filled with guys freaking out, calling misandry (while they insult women in a very ugly way). Learn to laugh and not be defensive jerks.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Never mind the bollocks...
nigel-188546 March 2018
Imagine submitting a script, the central theme of which were some ill conceived and self serving generalisations commonly held by ignorant men about women. This script wouldn't just be an example of stereotyping but a fully rounded rationalisation of prejudice, depicting woman as universally incapable of functioning independently, habitually stupid and selfish. What do you think the reception for that script would be, be honest, it's never going to fly is it?

Oddly but I admit none too surprisingly, the same isn't true if you simply transpose the gender roles. Yep you can get away with rendering bigotry on screen if you just take the time to select the -correct- subject matter. What's even odder though, is just how blithely this particular example negotiates this hypocrisy so un-self-consciously; there's not even a perfunctory attempt to qualify the crass reasoning it presents.

And this is where the paradox arises, the narrative presented is so crass and objectionable that it actually turns out to be quite an effective (probably unintentional) satire on feminism.
24 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The Goddess Must Be Crazy
It's 2055. Only women have survived the final, and biggest, war. We see a small farming community which also has teachers, and into this comes the other gender's extreme, thus contrasting and exploring their differences, strengths, weaknesses: a military man, Major Mercer(Keith, charming, determined) with working knowledge of engines and such awakens from 40 years of cryo-freeze. Different villagers react to him in distinct ways: one falls in love and wants to know more, one is completely against him, an elder one is reminded of her past, etc. But what will become of him? Can it even work, having such a group suddenly take in an outsider, simultaneously demonized and the subject of many imagined, distant scenarios?

This hits just the right balance. The conflict is neither cheesy nor vague. No one is purely the ideal they might be expected to be, every character has depth and is well-acted. And this doesn't off-handedly choose either side, rather, we see that a middle-ground may be the best solution, when this Bechdel-test-winner-by-design easily could have preached. Is more will-power needed in trade? Can his suggestions aid, or break, their ways... peaceful, yet marred by hardship? The storytelling and pace are swift: within mere minutes, the high concept(which could have come off as silly and contrived) is set up, then explained well without the exposition bogging things down(yes, sperm-banks). I was left to wonder why the pronunciation of only certain words had changed somewhat. There is tension, even some action in this. This is one of only episodes I've watched of either version of The Outer Limits, but, like the others, it fosters a desire to seek out more.

There is some disturbing content, sensuality and sexuality, as well as a little female nudity from behind(in the totally necessary and not gratuitous co-ed shower scene). I recommend this to any fan of science- and speculative, fiction. 8/10
13 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Masculinity So Fragile
natattack1011 September 2020
I have to laugh at the reviews calling this episode misandric and radically feminist. TOL is speculative fiction. It takes an idea and expands on it to explore facets of humanity and existence. Historically, wars and violence have been caused by men, not women. The writers of this episode explored a future where men (in general) cause their own extinction due to their own violence and aggression.

For an hour-long show, I think this was a well-told story. Mercer is a likable, noble character with good intentions. But the all-female enclave functions the way it does for a reason. Mercer rocks the boat, and tragedy ensues.

If you're watching this episode, I encourage you to watch it with an open mind. Reflect on the sex and gender dynamics that exist in our society. This story is just one interpretation, but it's not so far fetched or one-sided to be counted out for plausibility.
8 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Surprised this was made -- Some Spoilers
wbagot13 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
*** Some Spoilers Ahead ***

Surprised to find something like this in Outer Limits. Let's just say if it were reversed, it would have been considered a horrible form of women bashing, by a woman hating male chauvinist.

Apparently when left to their own, women thrive in peace and give selflessly of themselves for the good of their rulers, who have only their best interests at heart.

But if you interpose just one man, he will of course bring tyranny, might makes right, and do whatever he wants no matter what he's told. He will sow discontent, jealousy, division ... did I leave anything out?

Just in case this could have been viewed as an aberration,it turns out the same experiment was run with 11 different men ... and all of them caused the same upheaval and warfare ... human civilization is basically men trying to fight others, while women know only harmony, unless they are tarnished by men, "the devil."

It could have been a good episode about someone trying to adapt and survive in a different culture, where men and women appreciate the aspects that each brings to a society to make it better.

Yeah, right.

Apart from the very odd plot, which comes across as something written after drinking much alcohol after a bad breakup, the quality of the show isn't bad. The idea is intriguing, the acting is okay, the setting makes sense. It's just that it could have been such a good story ... and it wasn't.
23 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Only because I could not rate zero.
welambert0123 April 2020
My oh my! Ignoring the major plot hole of the reproduction process, if there's a worse episode of this run of The Outer Limits, please let me know as I need to avoid. The intent to showcase the evil of man; the result; pettiness of woman on display. My initial thought; only man, let me get out of here: end of the episode, proven correct. The writers do not understand the difference between submission and cooperation.
15 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The reviews on this are fascinating
onenonymouse18 August 2023
Half of the reviews think this is full of misogyny and the other half think it's misandry. Maybe not half and half, since possibly more men have reviewed it crying misandry. Personally I think the entire episode is just full of awful gender stereotypes all around. It's definitely got a fair amount of male fantasy (re: lesbian relationships in an all-male society, the pining of women for a man the second they see him, the need for a man to take charge of things). And the claim of some reviews that this represents some sort of utopian female society are bizarre, because clearly there are all sorts of problems with the society, which according to the writers clearly need a man to fix -- it's just that he goes about it wrong. But yes, it is also full of stereotypes about men being inherently violent and causing violence. And in the end it has a lot of anti-man rhetoric. So in my opinion this is just unfair to both men and women.

The biggest problem is that it's a silly story and the acting is mostly really bad. And the end is just more silliness.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
This episode is basically cliché porn written by a man
amandanw-7313116 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
This lame story seems to be just an excuse for porn. Throughout the episode are several scenes of nudity, kissing, and s3x among various women and one man. No surprise that the episode was written by a man. This is like a sick man's very cliché s3xual fantasy, imagining himself as the only man in a world of women... and little girls. There are scenes of nude young women showering together with their full bodies shown on the screen. And then several different young women get nakie with one of only 12 men left on the planet, doing it any various settings during various situations. And when the women get shot, of course they have to fall backwards head-first to the ground so we see up their skirt, not that it matters much since we've seen them all in their birthday suit already.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed