In Terrence Malick's world, the Earth - broadly, nature - is its own being in which we exist. His traditional philosophical definition of hard work (harvesting, making your own life in nature) initially explored in Days of Heaven has spotlight again here. Peace and happiness, love, the plentiful bounty of the Earth for humanity's taking and rejoicing within and without. And somehow, in just as breathtaking of a display, in just as lyrically romantic a form as Days of Heaven. Here we see the wide angles close to the characters face, the edges of the lens curving the character into their environment which immerses, withholds them (and us). Its ways, its energy is written in the DNA of Franz and Fani, their own morals and way of life--a loving relationship, a happy home. Pure presence in living. A true Christian existence if there ever was one. The characters' voices, so poetic and visceral as the speak their letters to each other, their emotions: "We lived above the clouds." More than anything, A Hidden Life is about the eternality of feeling heaven and maintaining it--if impossible without (as it was not in the beginning), then keeping it within. For it is an eternal experience, as Franz finds in opposition to the Nazis, a truly free one, to surrender to his own nature and what feels right to him. He narrates, "Once you give up surviving at any cost, another door opens..." The weight is lifted. Faith, an other-knowledge, the sun which still shines behind the tempest. Though utterly painful and ripping in every way possible--physical, mental--Franz knows his sentiment of love and life and literally acting this out--not cowardly holding it within while your conscience eats away at you--is one that can never die, for it speaks to nature itself. We see this reflected in the joyousness of Franz and Fani's love and family. When the Nazis come in, when the darkness takes over, the Earth itself changes. The clouds swirl and blacken, lighting strikes, thunder sounds. Though nature does not alter itself to humanity's choices, its indifference is a harsh one which allows humans to face the darkness their species has created. It is an all-knowing indifference.
The real historical footage of the Nazi movement in the beginning--later cross-cut with Franz's dark dreams and transportation--cuts like a blade to the heart. No wonder Malick spent years editing this film. He slashes at the purity of Franz's love with a terror of black and white, of evil. The helplessness of it. The darkness and unconsciousness also written in human nature (Days of Heaven echoes again). And even as the fearful Austrian community ostracizes Franz's family from not volunteering or answering his call to the Nazi military, even as they take him away and attempt to manipulate, torture and destroy his will, Franz looks up to the sky in his unbroken--but tested literally as far as it can be--faith.
My favorite scene in the movie is when after Franz is sentenced, after he refuses to sign the oath to Hitler that would let him go back, he is able to see his wife, Fani, one last time. Initially, in order to save his life, she asked Franz if he could answer the volunteer call - perhaps, if not to fight, then maybe he could work in a hospital, for example. For everyone knew what Franz's objections would bring--when the letter comes that he's been condemned to death, its shocking for Fani, yet in a way still not a surprise. But due to Fani's nature, the holy goodness she knows in Franz's heart, she cannot help but stand behind him. This is unspoken between them until she sees Franz before he's about to die. I want to cry just writing about it. Never before have I weeped so many times as I did at this movie. Anyways, amongst the Nazi lawyer and people still trying to convince him astray, Franz and Fani look at each other, meet each other like two reflected rays of sunlight concurrent against each other and Franz asks, "Do you understand?" Fani looks down, she looks back in his eyes, she nods a little, she says: "I am always with you. No matter what happens." For with the connection the lovers are a part of, the freedom they know within and without, they have found the timelessness of existence. And the further transcendence in Franz's pain, his dignity, highlights this to the extreme, when they are faced to lose what they always loved and they know they have never, will never lose it.
The heaven written in us and what we are connected to is love's manifestation in spirit. That is there without Franz and Fani and in them. And it is in the hills, the mountains and their serene, powerful curves of emotion. They are the mote and not the mote.
Franz and Fani's voices reading their letters back to one another during his incarceration serve the poetry in the martyrdom of the film--Jesus' real struggle, even though the Nazi's perpetuate Christianity, a very interesting statement which Malick makes through his characters of the church followers getting 'sympathy' from their religion without following the teachings. For if the townspeople understood the responsibility of uncowardly preserving love wherever they can, deciphering what has happened to their world, they would know the struggle of Jesus and Franz. In his hushed conversations with the other objector in his village, Franz's parallels of Hitler to the antichrist and of the Nazi regime of the beginning of the Christian-prophetized end of the world are interesting--it is a direct statement from Malick of God's, of nature's will broken, of a virtually unstoppable evil rising on this planet. Yet the freedom of resistance. These pressures--however little each of them, however massive--of conformity through fear, of anti-consciousness on Franz and his family's happiness, love and free will are all too real to human life then, now and much before. Look at how when Franz gets to higher and higher officers that try to convince him to fight, they are still plagued by the questions Franz is asking, what they--if they're being honest--initially felt and still feel. Unanswered questions that never stop biting deep inside. They have no answer, they cannot compute the will of Franz beyond them, they become frightened, they ask, "What good are you doing? It doesn't make a difference you resisting, does it? It doesn't help anyone?" Just as the Nazi mayor of the town became frightful of how the Nazis may punish him for allowing the breeding of a consciencious objector in his sect.
A Hidden Life includes us in its undying beauty, begs us to feel our own nature through Franz's family's love and peace in those lush, vivid green hills in their fog below the mountains. "We lived above the clouds," is perhaps our most direct parallel to heaven in the film. Franz's narration in the beginning mentions how he thought they could live in the isolation, the seclusion of the mountain and be untouched by the encroaching evil. Yet, Malick forces us to catharcize the ongoing failure of humanity to live in peace, and makes us realize something greater in nature: that every heaven will be ripped away somehow, in sometime, that perhaps the greatest part of being alive is to know how to not die in living--to transcend. In love and in pain. Malick speaks to the painfulness of the heaven you can feel of being alive on this Earth--this rare, rare, precious condition in space--and the hell of what this species has created for itself. The animalness of it.
I am an emotional wreck after seeing this movie. It rips my heart out in conveyal of the immortal peace I know, then repeatedly and fittingly so attempts to take it away--as the Nazis to do Franz in--and gives us the courage to hold onto it in onslaught of those painstakingly real omnipresent dogmas and pressures that destroy peace in existence by their perpetuation. The resistance, the fight, is our struggle and our duty to ourselves as it is to what made us--the powers of creation. In the expression of free truth there is no dying, only returning, ascending back to this for it is what we are. Like how the orthodx Hindu considers the experience of 'Self,' the spirit, a mere extension and direct inclusion of the timeless natural creator, both beyond and within us--only of the 'one breath' this film refers to. Our morals, ideals are written in our nature as humans just as our body is. A Hidden Life evokes something that I feel as deep as possible in my body, from my feet to my mind. Something body and mind create and share together in this unique experience. Both preserving and acting upon this is the purpose of life, a drive with no fear of death and no end--for it is for something much greater than a single life. And it is the greatest solace in a plight-filled, degrading world to be able to continue to feel this. It is feeling God and reflecting Heaven back onto Earth. Though we must remember that beyond any ideal, beyond any human construct of thought, Christ's mythical/legendary dilemma on the cross was to fight for who he was: God's son, though asked to renounce this. Like Franz, he was utterly free in his action from what he continued to feel, to protect inside. A Christian understanding that speaks much more to a faith bigger than any single religion, to the experience we know by being alive, that we hopefully continue be true to with the strength of whatever you call it--God, Brahman, etc. The force of the eternal, the creator within, who in life giveth and taketh away.
The real historical footage of the Nazi movement in the beginning--later cross-cut with Franz's dark dreams and transportation--cuts like a blade to the heart. No wonder Malick spent years editing this film. He slashes at the purity of Franz's love with a terror of black and white, of evil. The helplessness of it. The darkness and unconsciousness also written in human nature (Days of Heaven echoes again). And even as the fearful Austrian community ostracizes Franz's family from not volunteering or answering his call to the Nazi military, even as they take him away and attempt to manipulate, torture and destroy his will, Franz looks up to the sky in his unbroken--but tested literally as far as it can be--faith.
My favorite scene in the movie is when after Franz is sentenced, after he refuses to sign the oath to Hitler that would let him go back, he is able to see his wife, Fani, one last time. Initially, in order to save his life, she asked Franz if he could answer the volunteer call - perhaps, if not to fight, then maybe he could work in a hospital, for example. For everyone knew what Franz's objections would bring--when the letter comes that he's been condemned to death, its shocking for Fani, yet in a way still not a surprise. But due to Fani's nature, the holy goodness she knows in Franz's heart, she cannot help but stand behind him. This is unspoken between them until she sees Franz before he's about to die. I want to cry just writing about it. Never before have I weeped so many times as I did at this movie. Anyways, amongst the Nazi lawyer and people still trying to convince him astray, Franz and Fani look at each other, meet each other like two reflected rays of sunlight concurrent against each other and Franz asks, "Do you understand?" Fani looks down, she looks back in his eyes, she nods a little, she says: "I am always with you. No matter what happens." For with the connection the lovers are a part of, the freedom they know within and without, they have found the timelessness of existence. And the further transcendence in Franz's pain, his dignity, highlights this to the extreme, when they are faced to lose what they always loved and they know they have never, will never lose it.
The heaven written in us and what we are connected to is love's manifestation in spirit. That is there without Franz and Fani and in them. And it is in the hills, the mountains and their serene, powerful curves of emotion. They are the mote and not the mote.
Franz and Fani's voices reading their letters back to one another during his incarceration serve the poetry in the martyrdom of the film--Jesus' real struggle, even though the Nazi's perpetuate Christianity, a very interesting statement which Malick makes through his characters of the church followers getting 'sympathy' from their religion without following the teachings. For if the townspeople understood the responsibility of uncowardly preserving love wherever they can, deciphering what has happened to their world, they would know the struggle of Jesus and Franz. In his hushed conversations with the other objector in his village, Franz's parallels of Hitler to the antichrist and of the Nazi regime of the beginning of the Christian-prophetized end of the world are interesting--it is a direct statement from Malick of God's, of nature's will broken, of a virtually unstoppable evil rising on this planet. Yet the freedom of resistance. These pressures--however little each of them, however massive--of conformity through fear, of anti-consciousness on Franz and his family's happiness, love and free will are all too real to human life then, now and much before. Look at how when Franz gets to higher and higher officers that try to convince him to fight, they are still plagued by the questions Franz is asking, what they--if they're being honest--initially felt and still feel. Unanswered questions that never stop biting deep inside. They have no answer, they cannot compute the will of Franz beyond them, they become frightened, they ask, "What good are you doing? It doesn't make a difference you resisting, does it? It doesn't help anyone?" Just as the Nazi mayor of the town became frightful of how the Nazis may punish him for allowing the breeding of a consciencious objector in his sect.
A Hidden Life includes us in its undying beauty, begs us to feel our own nature through Franz's family's love and peace in those lush, vivid green hills in their fog below the mountains. "We lived above the clouds," is perhaps our most direct parallel to heaven in the film. Franz's narration in the beginning mentions how he thought they could live in the isolation, the seclusion of the mountain and be untouched by the encroaching evil. Yet, Malick forces us to catharcize the ongoing failure of humanity to live in peace, and makes us realize something greater in nature: that every heaven will be ripped away somehow, in sometime, that perhaps the greatest part of being alive is to know how to not die in living--to transcend. In love and in pain. Malick speaks to the painfulness of the heaven you can feel of being alive on this Earth--this rare, rare, precious condition in space--and the hell of what this species has created for itself. The animalness of it.
I am an emotional wreck after seeing this movie. It rips my heart out in conveyal of the immortal peace I know, then repeatedly and fittingly so attempts to take it away--as the Nazis to do Franz in--and gives us the courage to hold onto it in onslaught of those painstakingly real omnipresent dogmas and pressures that destroy peace in existence by their perpetuation. The resistance, the fight, is our struggle and our duty to ourselves as it is to what made us--the powers of creation. In the expression of free truth there is no dying, only returning, ascending back to this for it is what we are. Like how the orthodx Hindu considers the experience of 'Self,' the spirit, a mere extension and direct inclusion of the timeless natural creator, both beyond and within us--only of the 'one breath' this film refers to. Our morals, ideals are written in our nature as humans just as our body is. A Hidden Life evokes something that I feel as deep as possible in my body, from my feet to my mind. Something body and mind create and share together in this unique experience. Both preserving and acting upon this is the purpose of life, a drive with no fear of death and no end--for it is for something much greater than a single life. And it is the greatest solace in a plight-filled, degrading world to be able to continue to feel this. It is feeling God and reflecting Heaven back onto Earth. Though we must remember that beyond any ideal, beyond any human construct of thought, Christ's mythical/legendary dilemma on the cross was to fight for who he was: God's son, though asked to renounce this. Like Franz, he was utterly free in his action from what he continued to feel, to protect inside. A Christian understanding that speaks much more to a faith bigger than any single religion, to the experience we know by being alive, that we hopefully continue be true to with the strength of whatever you call it--God, Brahman, etc. The force of the eternal, the creator within, who in life giveth and taketh away.
Tell Your Friends